Carol Nolan criticises decade-long broadband delays
Carol Nolan criticised the rollout of the National Broadband Plan, calling the delays "absolutely shameful" and saying many rural and urban areas still lack access to high-speed fibre more than a decade after earlier reports. She described the plan as not credible, warned it has hampered businesses, and raised concerns about projected connection dates and the programme's costs.
Rollout delays and timeline
The deputy highlighted that comments by a government minister in 2013 and the plan's publication in 2012 followed earlier reports from the Next Generation Broadband Task Force in 2011, yet at the start of 2022 many areas remain without high-speed connections. She challenged government claims that the project is "gathering pace" and noted that National Broadband Ireland confirmed parts of her constituency, including areas around Clunnygown in Leash Offaly, have anticipated connection dates of January 2025 to December 2026.
Effect on businesses and remote work
Carol Nolan said the delay has hampered small employers, citing an employer in Rosnallis and County Leash with 30 employees who was told it would be a number of years before high-speed broadband is available. She warned that lack of infrastructure undermines job creation, deters local and foreign investment and makes proposed legislation to enable working from home impractical for many families.
Cost and funding questions
The deputy expressed serious concerns about the cost of the programme, comparing it to the National Children's Hospital and noting the base subsidy of 2.1 billion and a contingency subsidy of 480 million. She reported National Broadband Ireland saying it is early in the build phase but expects to keep close to the 2.1 billion base subsidy and asked what would happen if that target is not met.
Calls for scrutiny and engagement
Carol Nolan said the rural independent group has sought a briefing with National Broadband Ireland to address issues and secure firm commitments, urging elected representatives to critically evaluate the process. She called the prospect of constituents waiting until 2025-2026 for basic broadband unacceptable and demanded more constructive engagement and accountability from those responsible for the rollout.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Great to see you. And how are we? Can you introduce yourself? I am quite proud to be a colleague that she is in Toronto and a new city, that this is a good point, I'm so sorry, but it's not that I will go into the city of a city, but I will change my mind and take the data and show the infrastructure of oil. and is infrastructure banusac é ag daire an lé? The following comments were made by a Government Minister on the rollout of the National Broadband Plan. The Government's National Broadband Plan aims to radically change the broadband landscape in Ireland by ensuring that high-speed services are available to all of our citizens and businesses well in advance of the EU's target date of 2020 and that significantly higher speeds are available to as many homes and businesses as possible. That Minister was Minister Pat Rabbit. The year he made those comments in was 2013. One year after the National Broadband Plan was originally published in August 2012 and two years after the publication of the Next Generational Broadband Task Force report in 2011. Yet here we are at the start of 2022, more than a decade after the Next Generation Broadband Task Force report was published and many parts of rural Ireland and indeed urban Ireland are still without access to basic infrastructure, high-speed fibre connections. That is incredible. We have heard several government TDs making comments that this project is gathering pace. What do they mean exactly by gathering pace? We are going back as far as announcements in 2013 and here we are in 2022. It is absolutely shameful and I do not believe there is any excuse for such a delay. It certainly has hampered businesses. I have heard directly from many small employers, one employer in Rosnallis and County Leash, 30 employees, that he cannot get high-speed broadband in the area and was told it will be a number of years. If that is how employers are treated, no wonder we do not have enough jobs or enough job creation in rural Ireland. When we are being let down by a so-called plan, I do not believe it is a good plan, I do not believe it is credible. It is not credible to leave people waiting years and years for such basic infrastructure. I know ourselves in the rural independent group we have sought a briefing with National Broadband Ireland to discuss the many issues and indeed ask the questions that need to be asked because we do need proper constructive engagement and we do need firm commitments that we can stand over. To expect TDs to tell their constituents that they must wait until 2025-2026 for basic infrastructure such as National Broadband Ireland just does not cut it. It is certainly something that I do not think is acceptable in the least and certainly you know so much for gathering pace. I do not call that gathering pace if we have to wait that long and surely something can be done here because we know that in all of our communities there are areas affected and there are employers affected. There are businesses the length and breadth of the country and also it will hamper our chances of bringing in foreign direct investment or indeed in encouraging local enterprises to set up in a particular area or in a particular community. It is certainly holding back our local economy, it is certainly holding back potential by not having this infrastructure in place. There is something as I said radically wrong and I believe that we all need to be to be asking the questions of the National Broadband Plan. In my own constituency of Leash Offaly National Broadband Ireland have confirmed to me that while areas in Offaly such as those in and around Clunnygown are within its intervention area the anticipated connection date is January 2025 to December 2026. That as I said before is totally unacceptable particularly when the government is talking about legislation allowing people work from home and we are hearing this sort of thing and this sort of spin how can people work from home if they do not have basic broadband. It is certainly going to to put paid to that notion for many many families they just will not be able to do so and will have no option but to commute even if their employer is willing to let them work from home it cannot happen unless the infrastructure is there. I just feel that you know there is too much of a delay and there is acceptance around that from government which is very concerning. I would have thought that you would be more critically evaluating the whole process and asking the questions as elected representatives. I believe that is the proper role and indeed the proper way to pursue the issue but I do feel that you know it is so long since the report of the task force that I mentioned a moment ago 15 years minister. I have serious concerns. My concerns also relate to the actual cost of the project. I mean this is like something that is comparable to the National Children's Hospital it's 2.1 billion and that is very very concerning. We need to be asking questions as public representatives. I do apologise but I tried to give you a little bit leeway but I'm afraid your time is up. Apologies. Yeah but it's all about your time to talk to the government. I'm almost finished but I did have leeway because there's nobody else here in the group. Okay well it just allows you five minutes deputy on this so I'm just trying to stick to okay okay no no I I'm the only person I told the Count Corla when I came in that I was taking the time on behalf of the group. Okay well it's not on this now I'm afraid it gives your group five minutes. Yeah okay okay I'll just finish up yeah I'll just finish up. National Broadband Ireland have the cost of the programme is made up of a base subsidy of 2.1 billion and 480 million of a contingency subsidy plus fat. According to NBI it is very early in the build phase but the indications are it will be able to keep as close to the 2.1 billion base subsidy as possible. If this does not happen does the Minister I wonder anticipate increasing the existing 480 million contingency fund and if so at what level. As I said I have serious concerns around the cost of the project and indeed I have concerns and indeed I have very little confidence in the capability and indeed the ability of of this project of this scale to be delivered because it certainly is being delivered in a timely manner. Thank you Deputy. Thank you very much.
Thank you for downloading 🙏
If you publish this material on social media, we would be very grateful if you tagged VideoParliament. It helps us reach more people and keep building a transparent archive of Irish politics.
