Menu
VideoParliament
VideoParliament Irish politics in one place — download the app
Get app
VideoParliament
VideoParliament for Windows Get the desktop app — notifications about new speeches
Get app
Carol Nolan: Calls Energy Policy 'National Self-Sabotage'

Carol Nolan: Calls Energy Policy 'National Self-Sabotage'

Carol Nolan criticised the government's energy policy on 15 September 2022, calling the approach "an act of national self-sabotage" and accusing ministers of "green hysteria" and ideological ruthlessness. She warned the policies are driving up electricity bills in rural Ireland, demanded ministerial intervention with electricity companies and said the minister should consider resigning if power fails this winter.

Main accusations


Nolan said the current approach to energy policy and energy creation is an act of national self-sabotage and described it as an absolute disgrace. She accused ministers of pursuing green policies with ideological ruthlessness and said many who previously pushed for more aggressive measures have now "changed their tunes."

Effects on rural households and businesses


The deputy highlighted rapid bill increases in rural communities, saying publicans have seen their unit rate treble and farmers' bills rise from €400 to almost €1,600. She warned that many households face bills of several thousands of euro and that assurances from the minister and government offer no comfort.

Calls for ministerial action


Nolan demanded the minister intervene with electricity companies over high charges and called for immediate measures to relieve struggling households and businesses. She said if the lights go out this winter the minister should seriously consider resigning, arguing rural Ireland is "fed up" and can no longer accept the current situation.

Carol Nolan — clip from remarks: Carol Nolan: Calls Energy Policy 'National Self-Sabotage' (15.09.2022)

Policy critique and alternatives rejected


She criticised the government for refusing even an interim approach to fossil fuels and LNG and described current policies as unworkable, unsustainable and unforgivable. Nolan argued the drive to meet international targets resembles the demands of a cult rather than a proportional, common-sense response.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.

Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →

Transcript
Minister, let me be frank. The current approach to energy policy and energy creation is an act of national self-sabotage. It is an absolute disgrace. Indeed, the sense that people are getting is that our entire population has been taken hostage by a green hysteria and a demented level of ideological ruthlessness that is not grounded in any sense of proportion or rationality. And it is wonderful here this evening to hear many of those who were jumping up and down and saying that the green policies weren't going far enough, to see that they have now changed their tunes. It is great, wonderful. It is also wonderful to see that people are copping on to this nonsense, that many of our tariff cutters are back on the bogs where they should have been left all along. We are not listening to any more of the nonsense any longer in rural Ireland, Minister. And if the lights go out this winter, Minister, you should seriously think of resigning, because businesses and households, working families cannot cope, nor should they be meant to put up with the struggles. Because of your inadequacy and your lack of ability to intervene with the electricity companies, who are charging too much for bills. We know that. We see that. I have met publicans who have seen their unit rate trebling. I have met farmers who have seen their bills going from €400 to almost €1,600. That is not sustainable, Minister. You are responsible here. You must intervene. And I am calling on you to do so. And if you cannot do that, then maybe you should resign, and we would all breathe a sigh of relief in rural Ireland, because we are fed up, we have had enough of the nonsense. The so-called assurances provided by Minister Rhine and this hapless and hopeless government are dating so badly that they are beyond worthless. Nobody believes a word, and there will be no comfort in your promises when the bills of several thousands of euro drop through the inbox or onto the mat of many homes, who are struggling at this point to survive. Instead of adopting even an interim approach with respect to fossil fuels and LNG, this government have decided to push ahead with unworkable, unsustainable and unforgivable policies that are damning our people to a perilous few years. And for what? To reach some ludicrous international targets that have more in common with the sacrifices that a cult would demand, rather than any rational and proportional response or common sense. Where is common sense gone? Obviously, it is not too common. But, Minister, people have had enough, and rural Ireland has had enough of this nonsense. Thank you very much.