Carol Nolan accuses state of catastrophe in asylum and immigration
Carol Nolan addressed the minister, accusing the state of mismanaging immigration and 'bogus asylum seekers' and calling the outcome a social and economic catastrophe. She demanded an urgent overhaul of the immigration and IPAS systems, stricter vetting of asylum claimants and accommodation providers, faster deportations, and a dramatic reduction in numbers.
Main criticism
Carol Nolan told the minister that the current management of immigration and bogus asylum seekers has become "nothing short of a social and economic catastrophe." She said billions have been spent and that repeated warnings were dismissed or reframed, with officials treating the situation as an emergency that excused a lack of proper controls.
Vetting failures and accommodation providers
She raised explicit concerns about the lack of vetting for asylum claimants, delays in deporting asylum seekers with criminal pasts and many from safe countries, and the absence of checks on those providing IPAS accommodation. Nolan disputed descriptions of providers as merely "business people," saying some could be better described as gangsters and are profiting from an unchecked, unregulated and broken system.
NGOs, bureaucracy and political consequences
Nolan warned that the bill under discussion risks being bogged down in bureaucracy and exploited through loopholes sought by what she called overpaid NGOs determined to oppose necessary reform. She compared the situation to the UK, saying that rhetoric without meaningful action is causing public anger and political convulsion there and risks similar consequences here.
Calls for urgent reform and reductions
She called for urgent, dramatic action: an overhaul of the dysfunctional immigration and IPAS systems, strict vetting of providers and claimants, timely deportations, and a reduction in the numbers of economic migrants and bogus asylum seekers. Nolan insisted there should be no more excuses or deflection and demanded immediate, effective reform.
Closing remarks
The speech concluded with a repeated vocal refrain of "Goedemagad," uttered multiple times in succession as the speaker closed her remarks.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Minister, the way the immigration and bogus asylum seekers have been managed to date is nothing short of a social and economic catastrophe. I'm utterly convinced that this issue will come to define previous governments. Warning after warning was dismissed and was reframed. Warning after warning that the state was effectively being ripped off were ignored with the excuse that we were in an emergency and therefore proper controls did not apply. Billions have been spent and very likely billions more will be spent because this state has adopted the slowest possible approach to managing a crisis that has been plain for all to see except for those who wanted to push the de facto open border policies. Minister, if you want to see what talking tough and taking no meaningful action on the asylum and immigration chaos looks like and where it will lead to, then look no further than the UK. There, the entire political establishment is being convulsed by defections from the establishment parties. The people are fed up of governments who promised much but do little to deliver tough-sounding rhetoric with no actions. The same is true here. Our people here are angry at how unwilling or how powerless governments have been in dealing with this generational crisis. This bill promises much but my fear is that it will be bogged down in bureaucratic nonsense and loopholes sought and found by the overpaid NGOs who are determined to oppose all necessary reform. I have very serious concerns that I have raised many a time in this House regarding the vetting or the lack of vetting of bogus asylum seekers, the delays deporting asylum seekers with criminal pasts, many of whom come from safe countries, and no vetting of the providers of bypass accommodation. Now, they have been described here as business people. They're not all business people. Some of these providers could be better described as gangsters and have question marks over their suitability or the appropriateness of having those people involved in the provision of any type of accommodation. What vetting is being done there? Because I don't believe there's any vetting there either in terms of the providers and who's involved. We need an urgent overhaul of both our dysfunctional immigration system and the IPAS system in terms of who's providing the accommodation. Are those people checked? And my sense of it is that they weren't checked at any stage. None of them were. And some, as I say, are totally unsuitable. The people involved, as I say, gangsters and chancers, some of them who were involved in the provision of the accommodation, IPAS accommodation, they continue to profiteer from an unchecked, unregulated and broken system. And this is extremely alarming. And we need urgent, urgent action before it's too late on this. The last point I want to make is that I, as a representative here, want action. I want a dramatic reduction in the numbers of economic migrants and in the numbers of bogus asylum seekers entering our country. I want no more excuses and defection. We need reform urgently, as I say, in terms of the people coming in and the vetting system and lack of vetting and lack of urgent deportations and timely deportations. But also, there needs to be a vetting process in regard to the suitability of some of these providers. Because there's very, very serious question marks there. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad. Goedemagad.
Thank you for downloading 🙏
If you publish this material on social media, we would be very grateful if you tagged VideoParliament. It helps us reach more people and keep building a transparent archive of Irish politics.