Conor D McGuinness warns rent bill will shaft renters
Conor D McGuinness criticised the minister's rent bill, saying it introduces market rent resets that will "shaft" renters. He argued the legislation will drive repeated rent increases, weaken security of tenure and risk higher homelessness.
Main criticism
McGuinness said the central change in the bill is the introduction of market rent resets that allow rents to be reset to prevailing market levels at the start of new tenancies and again after fixed periods. He described this as a move away from rent restraint towards a system that makes sharp increases routine.
Market rent resets and timing
He warned that, from next year, new tenancies will increasingly be exposed to immediate market resets and that tenants after fixed periods will also face upward resets. He said the private rental sector's high turnover and short tenancies means these resets will become the default experience for many renters.
Impact on renters and stability
McGuinness argued the bill will not reduce rents, will not deliver stability and will not prevent homelessness, and that it locks higher rents into the future. He said renters will carry the risk and pain of the policy, facing sudden hikes they cannot plan for or absorb, and that insecurity will be embedded as a feature of the system.
Responsibility and political critique
He blamed the government and named parties and groups in the Dáil debate, saying Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, the Healey Ray Group and the Lowry Group have chosen to gut controls rather than strengthen them. He accused the government of siding with large investors seeking higher returns rather than renters trying to keep a roof over their heads.
Wider warnings and opposition
McGuinness referenced concerns from frontline homelessness organisations, including the Simon Communities of Ireland, that unaffordable rents drive homelessness and that upward resets risk undermining security of tenure. He concluded that Sinn Féin will oppose the bill and urged government policy to focus on reducing rents rather than driving them up.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Minister, your rip-off rent bill changes how renting is regulated and it's a shift that will make an already broken system even worse, if you could credit that. It will shaft renters. At a time when those renters are facing record rents and intense cost-of-living pressures, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, the Healey Ray Group and the Lowry Group have chosen to gut controls when you should be strengthening them. The central change in your legislation, Minister, is the introduction of these market rent resets. Under your model, rents can be reset to prevailing market levels at the start of new tenancies and again after fixed periods. We know that that's a clear move away from rent restraint and towards a system that ensures sharp increases become routine for renters. Rents are already far beyond what many households can afford. We know that supply is constrained because of the decisions of you as Minister but your predecessors as Minister and Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael over many years. And instead of acting to stabilise the market, instead of building homes, government is embedding a mechanism that will ensure rents rise again and again and again. This bill will not reduce rents. It will not deliver stability. It will not prevent homelessness. It locks higher rents into the future and leaves renters carrying all of the risk and all of the pain. It means a rental system designed to push rents higher and not lower. It means workers and families facing sudden rent hikes they cannot plan for or absorb. It means insecurity being built into the system as a feature, not treated as a failure. And it means the government choosing to side, as always, with large investors seeking higher returns rather than renters trying to keep a roof over their heads. The impact of this approach will be widespread. The private rental sector has high turnover and relatively short tenancies. And as a result, these resets will not be confined to a small group, as you tell the media and anybody who listened, but will over time become the default experience for most renters. So from next year, if this shoddy piece of legislation is forced through, and it looks like it will be despite there being none of your backbenchers here to hear the debate, from next year new tenancies will increasingly be exposed to immediate resets. Students entering the private rental sector will be caught by the same private, by the same approach. And over time, even tenants who have already endured no-fault evictions will face market resets after fixed periods. The direction of travel is very, very clear. And it belies you, Minister, to be open and honest about that. Something that you and your colleagues in government, including Minister Cummins, have failed to do thus far. Concern about this legislation are not confined to Sinn Féin and the opposition parties. Organisations working on the front line of homelessness, including the Simon Communities of Ireland, have warned that unaffordable rents are a direct driver of homelessness, and that your upward rent resets risk undermining security of tenure in practice. This bill rips off renters. It's higher rents, weaker security, and more people pushed to the edge. And Sinn Féin will oppose it, because renters cannot absorb any more pressure. The people I represent, the people we represent, cannot take any more. And government policy should be focused on reducing rents, not driving them up even further in the interests of those who tell you what to do and who designed this approach and this piece of legislation, Minister. Thanks, Deputy.
Thank you for downloading 🙏
If you publish this material on social media, we would be very grateful if you tagged VideoParliament. It helps us reach more people and keep building a transparent archive of Irish politics.
