Carol Nolan honours Shane, urges justice after unlawful death
Carol Nolan paid tribute to Shane and his family, condemning the treatment they faced and calling for action after his tragic and unlawful death by a reckless, cowardly criminal. She said she co-signed a private member's motion and urged reforms to prevent families being brutalised by the state, the courts and other authorities.
Carol Nolan highlighted a mother's unwavering love and a family's determination to overcome denials, bureaucratic indifference and hostility. She named Shane's mother Lucia as a model of persistence and noted the family's pain, including his sisters and his father Jim.
She recalled co-signing, with other members, a private member's motion calling for action and justice for Shane, and mentioned receiving a last email from Lucia in July following that effort. Nolan presented the motion as part of the push to secure accountability and change.
The speech criticised denials, bureaucratic indifference and the outright hostility some showed to owning up to the wrong done to Shane. Nolan warned against the brutalising treatment of families at the hands of the state, the courts and other authorities.
While acknowledging that nothing can return Shane to his family, she said action can be taken to ensure no other family endures similar treatment. Nolan described the proceedings as a small step toward justice and reform.
Tribute to Shane and his family
Carol Nolan highlighted a mother's unwavering love and a family's determination to overcome denials, bureaucratic indifference and hostility. She named Shane's mother Lucia as a model of persistence and noted the family's pain, including his sisters and his father Jim.
Political action and the private member's motion
She recalled co-signing, with other members, a private member's motion calling for action and justice for Shane, and mentioned receiving a last email from Lucia in July following that effort. Nolan presented the motion as part of the push to secure accountability and change.
Critique of institutions and authorities
The speech criticised denials, bureaucratic indifference and the outright hostility some showed to owning up to the wrong done to Shane. Nolan warned against the brutalising treatment of families at the hands of the state, the courts and other authorities.
Hope for reform and prevention
While acknowledging that nothing can return Shane to his family, she said action can be taken to ensure no other family endures similar treatment. Nolan described the proceedings as a small step toward justice and reform.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Carol Nolan warns forestry licensing chaos risks 12,000 jobs
Carol Nolan: ESP profits exposed - Bill needs real consumer relief
Carol Nolan urges new Taoiseach to act on health and rural jobs
Carol Nolan denounces Gresham House deal as a 'sell-out'
Carol Nolan Warns £146m Cut to Just Transition Hits Midlands
Carol Nolan Demands Greater Oversight of Housing Body Spending
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Brian Stanley
Brian Stanley: Opposes 100% Mortgages, Flags Rent vs Deposit Fairness
Mattie McGrath
Mattie McGrath demands public inquiry into O'Farrell case
Rose Conway-Walsh
Rose Conway-Walsh: Condemns State Failings, Backs O'Farl Family
Mattie McGrath
Mattie McGrath calls for external audit of paediatric pelvic surgeries
Gerard P. Craughwell
Gerard P. Craughwell Calls for Urgent Debate on Ukraine
Mary Lou McDonald
Deputy Mary Lou McDonald- speech from 27 May 2025
Transcript
A mother's unwavering love for her son, a family's courageous determination to overcome the obstacles, denials, bureaucratic indifference and the outright hostility of some to own up to the wrong perpetrated upon Shane has brought us to this day. The last email I received from Shane's mother, Lucia, was back in July after I co-signed, along with other members, the private member's motion calling for action and justice for Shane. Lucia has always been a model of that fiercely protective love that the Irish mammy and mothers are known for. She is a model to us all on the value of persistence and indeed the pursuit of justice. Her beloved son Shane never left her heart before or after the moment of his tragic and unlawful death by a reckless, cowardly criminal. We are here today to honour Shane and his family, his sisters and his dad Jim. Nothing we can do can return Shane to his family, but we can take action to ensure that no family ever has to endure this kind of brutalising treatment at the hands of the state and indeed the courts and other authorities. I hope today is a small step in that direction. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.