Paul Donnelly: Garda Resources Fail Local Communities
Paul Donnelly challenged the Minister in parliament over policing failures, focusing on under-resourced Gardaí and the rise of scrambler activity in Dublin 15. He argues the Minister must act to provide resources, legislation and visible enforcement so communities can use public spaces safely.
Paul Donnelly describes frontline pressure on Gardaí, citing reports from Dublin 15 where parks have become dominated by groups on scramblers despite recent investment. He says guards are under-equipped and understaffed, and that targets for enforcement are repeatedly missed.
Donnelly highlights a disconnect between training and operational capability, noting new recruits complete lengthy training but still cannot drive emergency vehicles with blue lights. He contrasts Irish practice with a dedicated anti-scrambler unit in Britain and calls for similar resourcing and legislation here.
Using a local park example, Donnelly stresses the human impact: residents afraid to use public spaces and guards who are 'taunted' daily by scrambler riders. He places responsibility squarely on the Minister, insisting on immediate, tangible measures to restore safety and visible policing.
Donnelly urges clearer enforcement, dedicated resources and legislative support to tackle scrambler crime and protect communities. He warns that without these changes public confidence in policing will continue to erode and demands the Minister deliver on measurable action now.
Policing shortfall
Paul Donnelly describes frontline pressure on Gardaí, citing reports from Dublin 15 where parks have become dominated by groups on scramblers despite recent investment. He says guards are under-equipped and understaffed, and that targets for enforcement are repeatedly missed.
Training and enforcement gap
Donnelly highlights a disconnect between training and operational capability, noting new recruits complete lengthy training but still cannot drive emergency vehicles with blue lights. He contrasts Irish practice with a dedicated anti-scrambler unit in Britain and calls for similar resourcing and legislation here.
Local impact and demand for action
Using a local park example, Donnelly stresses the human impact: residents afraid to use public spaces and guards who are 'taunted' daily by scrambler riders. He places responsibility squarely on the Minister, insisting on immediate, tangible measures to restore safety and visible policing.
Consequences and next steps
Donnelly urges clearer enforcement, dedicated resources and legislative support to tackle scrambler crime and protect communities. He warns that without these changes public confidence in policing will continue to erode and demands the Minister deliver on measurable action now.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Pearse Doherty
Pearse Doherty: ARP is Deeply Unfair, Amendments Needed
Danny Healy-Rae
Danny Healy-Rae: Garda gaps leaving Kerry exposed to drugs
Cormac Devlin
Cormac Devlin: Backs ARP Extension, Warns on Rental Pressure
Paul Murphy
Paul Murphy: Two cents off oil is not enough
John McGuinness
John McGuinness: Administration failing - consumers pay
Alice-Mary Higgins
Alice-Mary Higgins: Migration, Public Interest, and Rights
Transcript
Minister, there's not a community out there that believes you have a handle on the policing issues that they face every single day. And I want to commend the guards in Dublin 15. They work hard under huge pressure. And I hear from them all of the time that they're under-resourced in terms of equipment, but also in terms of backup. Can you imagine how the general population feel? Last Sunday, I was sent a picture of a local park by local residents. About a dozen people hanging around the place. There's about six to eight scramblers flying around the park. Millions has been spent on that park. Millions. And yet a lot of people fear that they can't use it if it's not dealt with. And there has been work done in relation to scramblers. I absolutely acknowledge that. But the problem is there's very little enforcement because the guards don't have the resources. They don't have the numbers. You fail every single year to reach your target. And yet, even today, part of the line about more guarding on the streets and people just don't see them. I'll give you an example. Bizarrely, they're coming out of their nine-month-long training, two-year-long training, unable to drive cars with the blue lights on. Now, they can march because we've been down there and have seen it. It's part of the passing out of a relative. But they can march. They've spent hours on practice on how to march. But yet, they come out of there not being able to drive cars with the blue lights on. That is just absolutely ludicrous. They're taunted on a daily basis by people on scramblers. And yet they don't have the resources to be able to do it. The resources there, I've said this time and time again, that the resources that are in Britain are used to deal with an anti-scrambler unit, a dedicated unit. You need to ensure that it is resourced, that they have the legislation in place to enforce what we need to see on the ground, which is people's happiness. The book stops with you, Minister. That's where it stops. And people want to see action.