Paul Murphy: Govt's 10c Fix Won't Stop Profiteering
Paul Murphy responds to Minister Timmy Dooley's radio explanation of the government's new package, arguing the measures are linked to the protests and are insufficient to protect households. He warns the 10 cent kerosene relief will be wiped out by rises in the international price of oil and renews his call for price controls and universal supports.
Minister Timmy Dooley told a radio audience that the government's package is not connected to the recent protests or blockades, blaming higher international oil prices for undermining earlier measures. Paul Murphy challenges that account, saying nobody believes the package is unconnected to public pressure and that the government's small kerosene payment is tokenistic.
Murphy says he warned in the parliamentary debate that without price controls the government would be exposed to volatile international oil prices. He points to a bill introduced two years ago that would allow the state to set prices and argues this is the only way to stop profiteering and give people certainty about energy costs.
Murphy restates demands made on the streets: a universal 500 euro energy credit, measures to end dependence on fossil fuels and immediate introduction of free public transport. He argues those measures must accompany any short-term relief to protect households from ongoing price shocks.
Murphy says the recent protests showed ordinary people can force change and that Parliament must match that pressure with meaningful action on the cost of living. He calls for continued public mobilisation in the coming weeks to ensure the government delivers stronger, universal measures.
Minister's claim and Murphy's response:
Minister Timmy Dooley told a radio audience that the government's package is not connected to the recent protests or blockades, blaming higher international oil prices for undermining earlier measures. Paul Murphy challenges that account, saying nobody believes the package is unconnected to public pressure and that the government's small kerosene payment is tokenistic.
Why price controls matter:
Murphy says he warned in the parliamentary debate that without price controls the government would be exposed to volatile international oil prices. He points to a bill introduced two years ago that would allow the state to set prices and argues this is the only way to stop profiteering and give people certainty about energy costs.
Proposals and universal measures:
Murphy restates demands made on the streets: a universal 500 euro energy credit, measures to end dependence on fossil fuels and immediate introduction of free public transport. He argues those measures must accompany any short-term relief to protect households from ongoing price shocks.
Public pressure and next steps:
Murphy says the recent protests showed ordinary people can force change and that Parliament must match that pressure with meaningful action on the cost of living. He calls for continued public mobilisation in the coming weeks to ensure the government delivers stronger, universal measures.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Paul Murphy urges Tesco to meet Mandate, backs librarians
Paul Murphy: Backs Opt-Out Organ Donation Bill, Warns ICU Crisis
Paul Murphy Demands External Inquiry After Courtroom Exclusion
Paul Murphy condemns EU over Greece border crackdown
Paul Murphy: Demands End to Legal Sub-Minimum Pay for Youth
Paul Murphy on 'stroke politics' and Lowry-O'Brien scandal
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Jennifer Murnane O'Connor
Jennifer Murnane O'Connor: Urgent warning on fuel costs
Peter Burke
Peter Burke: Defends €750m Fuel Support Against Sinn Féin
Matt Carthy
Matt Carthy to Vote No Confidence Tonight
Martin Heydon
Martin Heydon: 'It is my job to fight for agriculture'
Simon Harris
Simon Harris: Calls Sinn Féin No-Confidence Motion a Stunt
Ivana Bacik
Ivana Bacik: Labour Has No Confidence in Government
Transcript
Minister Timmy Dooley was on the radio this morning and was explaining why the government has introduced this new package and he claimed of course it has nothing to do with the protests it had nothing to do with the blockades nobody believes that but instead he said it's because the measures that we introduced a number of weeks ago were wiped out by the international price of oil going up how could he have known that this would happen how could the government have known well we warned you we warned you in that debate that unless you introduced price controls precisely that would happen and so what will happen with the meagre 10 cents the nothing that's been given in terms of kerosene what will happen to that quite likely that will also be wiped out by an increase in the international price of oil what's the alternative the alternative is to have price controls to give people security to stop profiteering to let people know that this is going to be the price that's what we need to do the government has the power to do it with a bill that we introduced two years ago to do it people were on the streets over the past week demanding it that has to be matched with universal measures like a 500 euro energy credit and measures to stop our reliance on fossil fuel immediately we need to have free public transport the force to do that is ordinary people but the Parliament does the streets can undo that's what we've seen over the past week and that's what we need to see in the coming weeks to force meaningful action on cost of living to protect people