Richard Boyd Barrett: Why Capital Radiation Plans Are Blocked
Richard Boyd Barrett questions why capital investment for radiation oncology remains stalled despite apparent funding and clear benefit. He calls for the Taoiseach or the Minister for Health to instruct the HSE to implement a multi-annual planned replacement programme to improve productivity and patient flow.
Richard Boyd Barrett outlines his frustration that what he calls a "no-brainer" capital programme for radiation oncology has not been implemented. He argues that this is not about day-to-day savings but about capital expenditure and planned multi-annual replacement that could increase productivity.
He says the decision must come from the top - either the Taoiseach or the Minister for Health - and that the HSE needs direct instruction to get the rollout done. Barrett recounts meetings with colleagues and ministry officials, noting reassuring noises but no decisive action.
Barrett stresses that the rollout programme is the practical answer to getting patients through the system and improving how radiation oncology is delivered. He warns that bureaucratic perfectionism is becoming an obstacle to progress rather than a cost-saving measure.
He presses for clarity on where pressure must be applied - to ministers or departments - and insists that top-level direction is required to break the deadlock and deliver the programme that would enhance productivity and patient care in Ireland.
Central argument
Richard Boyd Barrett outlines his frustration that what he calls a "no-brainer" capital programme for radiation oncology has not been implemented. He argues that this is not about day-to-day savings but about capital expenditure and planned multi-annual replacement that could increase productivity.
Where responsibility lies
He says the decision must come from the top - either the Taoiseach or the Minister for Health - and that the HSE needs direct instruction to get the rollout done. Barrett recounts meetings with colleagues and ministry officials, noting reassuring noises but no decisive action.
Consequences for patients
Barrett stresses that the rollout programme is the practical answer to getting patients through the system and improving how radiation oncology is delivered. He warns that bureaucratic perfectionism is becoming an obstacle to progress rather than a cost-saving measure.
What he demands next
He presses for clarity on where pressure must be applied - to ministers or departments - and insists that top-level direction is required to break the deadlock and deliver the programme that would enhance productivity and patient care in Ireland.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Holly Cairns
Holly Cairns: Four Years of Delay on Short‑Term Lets
Pádraig Mac Lochlainn
Pádraig Mac Lochlainn: Redress Scheme Spreads Injustice East
Tom Clonan
Tom Clonan: Irish alumina fuelling Russian weapons
Nina Carberry
Nina Carberry urges EU to criminalise severe online abuse
Alan Kelly
Alan Kelly: End Blanket Secrecy in Family Courts Now
Charles Ward
Charles Ward: Defective Concrete scheme delays trap families
Transcript
I kind of think I understand, but then on the other hand I still am struggling to understand how they haven't sorted this out. Do you know, like, because I can understand them, and I don't agree with them, penny-pinching on current expenditure, but on capital expenditure the kind of, even that sort of, you know, first of all they're saying it's a different type of expenditure, you know, and we've lots of money for capital expenditure, and there's no real, there's no cost of doing what you're saying, in fact there might even be a saving of what you're proposing is a multi-annual planned replacement program. So you kind of wonder why there's any blockage to this at all, I mean, is there anything more we can say, like, or you can tell us about where we have to put the pressure on, is it with the ministers, with the department, because I mean I raised this when I got back into the Dáil, and I kind of got reassuring noises from the minister that, oh yeah, we're gonna take this seriously, we're gonna look at it, and I'm struggling to understand why something that seems to be a no-brainer still isn't happening. We've spoken to so many people, John and I have done so many meetings, we've been here, Gerry's been here before, it seems to me that the decision has to come from the top, whoever is at the top, but be that on Taoiseach, be that the Department of Health, it has to come from there, because I can't see it happening in any other department, based on our conversations. I agree. I think that's the case, we need either on Taoiseach or the Minister of Health to instruct the HSE to get this done, whatever, get this done, and however, and somehow, as you say, we are, there is a perfection of the progress of, you know, or, you know, progress, is our enemy of progress, in this state we really do, as John said, there seems to be a disabling bureaucracy that's not actually saving us money, it's not costing us money, you know. And there was somebody, well, the points earlier around productivity, I mean, the ultimate answer to getting patients through the system is this rollout programme, like that is the solution to getting patients through the system, and making it more productive in how we treat patients with radiation oncology in Ireland.