Verona Murphy: Online Anonymity Is Silencing Democracy
Verona Murphy warns that fake and anonymous online accounts are driving decent people out of politics and calls for accountability and identification to protect democratic participation. She urges parliamentarians to act together and says the issue should be revisited in Dublin in 2027.
Main argument
Verona Murphy argues that parliamentary democracy depends on decent people willing to stand for election, and that anonymous online impersonation, intimidation and distortion are not free speech but the silencing of democracy before it begins.
Accountability and identification
Murphy urges stronger accountability for those who profit from online platforms and insists that identifying where harmful speech comes from is essential so those responsible can be held to account, without curbing legitimate free speech.
International cooperation and timing
She stresses this is not a problem any single country can solve alone and calls on parliamentarians to confront the issue together, keeping it at the forefront of discussions and returning to it in Dublin in 2027.
Why this matters
Murphy warns that if the trend continues we will narrow the field of people willing to serve and weaken the quality of those who do, making the protection of democratic participation an urgent policy priority.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Parliamentary democracy depends on one thing above all else. Decent people willing to stand for election. And increasingly, many will not. Not because of free press. Not because of free speech. But because fake and anonymous online accounts are driving them out before they ever reach the ballot paper. They impersonate. They intimidate. They distort. And that's not free speech. It is the silencing of democracy before it even begins. If that continues, we narrow the field of those who are willing to serve. And we weaken the quality of those who wish to do so. This is not a challenge that any one country can address here. But it is one, as parliamentarians, that we must confront together. By setting clear expectations and by strengthening accountability. And by ensuring that those who seek to undermine democratic participation cannot do so without consequence. And we must do this in real time. So, these are issues that must remain to the forefront of our considerations. And I think it is certainly something that we will return to again in Dublin in 2007. Thank you. Thank you, Verona. In 2027, excuse me. Yeah, thank you. But if you could just, you said, it must have consequences. Could you in a few words just say, like what? Well, again, it's not something that anybody can, there's a lot of hostility around what those consequences might be. Because of the impression that we are trying to curb free speech. It is not about free speech. Because those who are, everybody has the right to free speech. As long as you can identify where the speech is coming from. So, I think it's about making those who are making the profits accountable for identifying if harm is caused. And that's the reality. We must be able to identify everybody so that they can be equally accountable. Thank you very much. Thank you.
Thank you for downloading 🙏
If you publish this material on social media, we would be very grateful if you tagged VideoParliament. It helps us reach more people and keep building a transparent archive of Irish politics.
