Martin Daly urges reform to rigid school transport rules
Martin Daly addressed the minister on school transport, arguing the current system is too rigid and urging implementation of the review's recommendations to provide certainty and capacity. He said school transport is not a luxury and called for changes to the nearest school rule, increased capacity, and measures to make bus driving an attractive career.
Martin Daly highlighted that 180,000 children rely on the school transport service and said the system as it stands is too rigid and inflexible. He warned that when a child's nearest school is full parents may secure a school place but not a seat on the bus because of the nearest school rule, leaving families without a way to get their children to school.
He described acute problems in Bannanislaw, where the presence of Porto Yonkla Hospital leads to a constant turnover of medical staff, registrars, consultants and essential workers who move to the town with their families. Those families often find no school transport available at primary or post-primary level, creating serious logistical pressures for parents working long hours, on-call rosters and shift work.
The review of the school transport scheme recommended reducing the distance criteria and removing the strict requirement to attend the nearest school in situations where existing bus routes already serve the area or where there is sufficient parental demand. Martin Daly called these recommendations sensible and pragmatic, but stressed they must be implemented carefully and effectively.
He identified capacity as the central challenge, urging investment in enough buses, enough drivers and proper planning so every eligible child who applies on time is guaranteed a seat. He argued bus driving must be made a more attractive career with secure hours, fair pay and a pipeline of trained drivers to meet growing demand.
Martin Daly noted parents are willing to pay the modest fees of €50 for a primary pupil and €75 for a post-primary pupil with a family cap of €125, but emphasised that what families really need is certainty of transport availability. He said there is a real opportunity to get the scheme right if the review's recommendations are followed through and capacity is invested to deliver a fair, reliable and sustainable service.
Key points of the intervention
Martin Daly highlighted that 180,000 children rely on the school transport service and said the system as it stands is too rigid and inflexible. He warned that when a child's nearest school is full parents may secure a school place but not a seat on the bus because of the nearest school rule, leaving families without a way to get their children to school.
Local impact in Bannanislaw
He described acute problems in Bannanislaw, where the presence of Porto Yonkla Hospital leads to a constant turnover of medical staff, registrars, consultants and essential workers who move to the town with their families. Those families often find no school transport available at primary or post-primary level, creating serious logistical pressures for parents working long hours, on-call rosters and shift work.
Recommendations from the review
The review of the school transport scheme recommended reducing the distance criteria and removing the strict requirement to attend the nearest school in situations where existing bus routes already serve the area or where there is sufficient parental demand. Martin Daly called these recommendations sensible and pragmatic, but stressed they must be implemented carefully and effectively.
Capacity and workforce solutions
He identified capacity as the central challenge, urging investment in enough buses, enough drivers and proper planning so every eligible child who applies on time is guaranteed a seat. He argued bus driving must be made a more attractive career with secure hours, fair pay and a pipeline of trained drivers to meet growing demand.
Parents' contribution and next steps
Martin Daly noted parents are willing to pay the modest fees of €50 for a primary pupil and €75 for a post-primary pupil with a family cap of €125, but emphasised that what families really need is certainty of transport availability. He said there is a real opportunity to get the scheme right if the review's recommendations are followed through and capacity is invested to deliver a fair, reliable and sustainable service.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Joe O'Reilly
Joe O'Reilly urges action plan to expand collective bargaining
Paul Murphy
Paul Murphy: Urges Ban on Algorithmic Targeting of Children
Carol Nolan
Carol Nolan slams carbon tax, calls for action on energy crisis
Brian Stanley
Brian Stanley urges raising driver age limit to 75 for school transport
Danny Healy-Rae
Danny Healy-Rae challenges age and bus rules hurting school transport
Richard O'Donoghue
Richard O'Donoghue urges 70-year bus drivers, decries delays
Transcript
Minister, I just want to acknowledge your exceptional commitment to your brief since you were appointed and your approachability at all times to help us solve our problems in our constituencies. Minister, school transport is not a luxury. It is a necessity for thousands of families, including many in my constituency. Every school day, 180,000 children rely on the service, which is one of the largest logistical operations managed by the State. However, the system as it stands is too rigid and inflexible. When a child's nearest school is full, parents are often left with no choice but to enrol their child in another school in a different locality, yet they are not guaranteed a seat on the bus because of the nearest school rule. This leaves families in an impossible position. They have secured a school place for their child, but they cannot get them there. In Bannanislaw, this problem is especially evident. The presence of Porto Yonkla Hospital means that there is a constant turnover of medical staff, registrars, consultants and essential workers who move to the town with their families. These families are essential to the running of the hospital and to the provision of health care in the region. Yet too often they find that no school transport is available for their children at either primary or post-primary level. This creates serious logistical pressures for parents who are working long hours, on-call rosters and shift work in a busy regional hospital. The review of the school transport scheme highlighted many of these issues and made welcome recommendations. These included reducing the distance criteria and removing the strict requirement to attend the nearest school in situations where existing bus routes already serve the area or where there is sufficient parental demand. These are sensible, pragmatic proposals, but they must be implemented carefully and effectively. Capacity remains the central challenge. We need enough buses, enough drivers and proper planning to ensure that every eligible child who applies on time is guaranteed a seat. Part of the solution must involve making bus driving a much more attractive career with secure hours, fair pay and a pipeline of trained drivers so that we can meet growing demand. Parents are willing to pay the modest fees of €50 for a primary pupil and €75 for a post-primary pupil with a family cap of €125. But what they really need is certainty that transport will be available. I believe now there is a real opportunity to get this right. If we follow through on the recommendations of the review and invest in the necessary capacity, we can deliver a scheme that is fair, reliable and sustainable, and that meets the needs of families into the future. Thank you very much. Thank you.