Menu
VideoParliament
VideoParliament Irish politics in one place — download the app
Get app
VideoParliament
VideoParliament for Windows Get the desktop app — notifications about new speeches
Get app
Carol Nolan demands single authority for Shannon flooding

Carol Nolan demands single authority for Shannon flooding

Carol Nolan spoke in the Dáil on ongoing flooding in the Midlands and rural Ireland, urging concrete action and a single management authority for the River Shannon. She criticised the slow response from government bodies and called for an end to repeated reports in favour of focused, tangible measures to protect farmers, homes and livelihoods.

Local impact and examples


The speaker described significant flooding during the summer along the Shannon, noting farmers' land was flooded, livestock had to be moved and there was confusion over the gates at Mielek. She highlighted West Offaly as an area of particular concern with about 200 farmers affected, and mentioned Riverstown, which straddles the Tipperary-Offaly border, and issues involving the River Brosna.

Economic and personal consequences


The speech emphasised the severe consequences of flooding - emotional stress, loss of homes, potential loss of farmland or businesses, health issues and declines in local economic competitiveness. Nolan said many farmers have grazing land usable for only two months of the year and face the real risk of fodder shortages.

Calls for a single management authority


Nolan urged the creation of one management authority to manage the River Shannon, arguing the current arrangement causes huge confusion and forces local representatives to move between the OPW, Waterways Ireland, the ESB and the minister's office. She presented a single agency as a pragmatic response to a complex problem.

Criticism of reports and government response


The deputy criticised the Catchment Flood Risk Assessment and Management programme for producing reports over the best part of a decade with little visible action. She said the minister speaks sincerely about addressing the matter but highlighted a repeated lack of tangible outcomes and cited an oral priority question being ruled inadmissible by the minister's department.

Carol Nolan — shot from statement: Carol Nolan demands single authority for Shannon flooding (03.11.2020)

Call for a whole-of-government approach


Nolan insisted the issue requires a whole-of-government response and asked colleagues to be constructive in formulating lasting solutions. She said she would welcome real change and pleaded for an end to what she described as lethargic responses and wasted time on reports.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.

Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →

Transcript
Thank you very much. I'm very happy to speak on this motion here today. This is an issue that has generated significant concern within the Midlands and indeed right across rural Ireland. And I'm indeed one of those frustrated TDs that Deputy Canny referred to. I know during the summer months there in July, we had issues along the Shannon where farmers' land was flooded. A lot of farmers were affected. Livestock had to be moved. And there was huge confusion over the gates at Mielek. And I remember contacting your office minister and also the OPW. But this is a reoccurring thing. I mean, I remember raising this issue when I was a County Councillor in 2014. And it's just going on too long. And I hope that tonight won't be a meaningless talking shop again. We need concrete actions. People are becoming very frustrated and angry over the whole issue. And I sincerely hope that we can all be constructive and work together in terms of formulating solutions once and for all to this ongoing issue that people really want resolved. Flooding, as we know, has far reaching negative and devastating impacts such as emotional stress, the loss of individual homes in cases and the loss of maybe farmland or businesses, severe associated health issues and dramatic declines in economic competitiveness within impacted communities and regions. I accept that Minister O'Donovan is sincere when he speaks about his desire to have these matters addressed. But as always, the real issues relate to the lack of tangible outcomes. Time and time again, my colleagues have called on the Department and indeed the OPW to immediately escalate its response to ongoing flooding issues affecting farmers and residents, particularly in West Offaly, where there are about 200 farmers affected from flooding. It's also caused by the River Shannon. And in Riverstown also a village which straddles the Tipperary-Offaly border. There is an issue there with the River Brosna also. So we need to get to grips with those, Minister, and I'm highlighting them here again tonight in the hope that we can get solutions in place. Unfortunately, what has been seen, and I hope this will change, but the response to this issue from the government's side has been lethargic at best. I'm constantly in contact with a number of farmers from West Offaly, and they are profoundly alarmed at the apparent lack of action. Many of them have grazing land that can only be used for two months of the year. So they are at risk of encountering fodder shortages. It's just unbelievable the stress and hardship that they have to endure. And I'm calling for that to end here tonight. I've always maintained, however, that this matter demands a whole of government approach. Because the nature of the damage to farms, as well as the threat, the provision of fodder that the flooding is bringing about is great. Unfortunately, and I have said this before, for a significant number of farmers in Offaly, and indeed right across the Midlands, the rains and the flooding are becoming as predictable as the government's lack of response. And I say with sincerity, I really hope that changes and that we can see a change in that. And I'll come back and I'll be the first person to welcome any such change. We know that Ireland's Catchment Flood Risk Assessment and Management program has been meeting for the best part of a decade to develop strategies for the reduction of risk. And I just become very cynical about all of the reports produced and no actions. If we could agree just a small few actions in those reports and carry them through. Because there's a terrible problem here. It just seems to be reports all of the time. Indeed, I remember being in Offaly County Council discussing these reports and the time wasted. And I can honestly say very, very little was done. So I would like to see an end of the reports and more action and focused actions. You know, the issue that the motion highlights when it calls for a single agency to be set up, I believe that that is definitely an urgent need. There is huge confusion. I mean, I remember being contacted in July by farmers and I was running from the OPW to the ESB to the Minister's office. And it's just a disaster. We need one management authority that will effectively manage the River Shannon. And it's just a pragmatic response to a difficult and complex issue. Despite the fact that, you know, there has been much highlighting of this issue, I had an oral priority question ruled inadmissible by Minister Ryan's department. And I just wonder, like the Green Party are full of aspiration, but they don't seem to care about communities in rural Ireland that are being flooded. The parliamentary question that I submitted specifically dealt with issues related to Waterways Ireland, which falls under the remit of Minister Ryan's department. Yet it was rejected. And this is not the kind of engagement that I or any other rural deputy in this House deserves or wants to see going forward. Thank you.