Menu
VideoParliament
VideoParliament Irish politics in one place — download the app
Get app
VideoParliament
VideoParliament for Windows Get the desktop app — notifications about new speeches
Get app
Mattie McGrath criticises online learning as a website, urges campus support

Mattie McGrath criticises online learning as a website, urges campus support

Mattie McGrath spoke on 11 March 2021 about the impact of COVID on higher education, arguing that online provision has fallen short and left students with an inadequate "website" experience. He praised People Before Profit for the motion and called for greater engagement from university management and better support for regional campuses.

Motion and opening remarks


McGrath thanked People Before Profit for tabling the motion and welcomed contributions from KDL, Dina Goberance and Susie, noting their hard work. He framed the debate as timely and necessary to address long-standing inequalities in the education sector.

Critique of online learning


He said the COVID calamity should have been an opportunity to overhaul third-level education but instead left students with a poor online experience - "literally... the same as giving us a website". He criticised university management for offering passive online delivery rather than interactive, adaptive learning.

Impact on students and campus life


McGrath stressed the loss of in-person interaction for students, highlighting the disruption for those transitioning from sixth year to first year. He argued campuses must enable more on-site functions and physical engagement so students can learn, express themselves and fulfil their potential despite COVID restrictions.

Mattie McGrath — still from remarks: Mattie McGrath criticises online learning as a website, urges campus support (11.03.2021)

Regional infrastructure and campus moves


He urged support for regional higher education initiatives, including the University of the South East and the relocation plans for LIT Tipperary to a former barracks site. McGrath said these moves and regional investment are badly needed to address rural discrimination and improve access to third-level education.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.

Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →

Transcript
Marko, I too want to thank the People Before Profit for putting down this motion, it's very timely and a very interesting debate, and a debate we should have, on the KDL, she's brought up a week ago all done, Dina Goberance and Susie, they do a very hard and dedicated job and they're very helpful, and it has settled down now from when it started, but there's huge discrimination for rural people, and the Covid, while it was a calamity, it should have given us the opportunity to have a real, to catch the total level education sector by the scruff of the nick, and give it a good shaking, because there's a lot of dead water, there's a lot of inequalities in it, and there's a lot of change that's needed there, badly needed change, I could mention the University of the South East, which we badly needed ministers, I don't know where the ministers, I can't see them, but he's there somewhere I know, or taught you, taught you himself, badly needed, and I have to go to spec service, badly needed for the South East, also our own situation in Conmel with the LIT Tipperary, and the move from his present site, site and the bypass to the, all kicking barracks, a wonderful site and great plans for it, but we need that move supported. Minister, I just spoke to my own daughter, who was in UL, just before I came in, and it's just like having a website provided, I mean, it could have been much more, learning online, but it's literally, as she said, it's the same as giving us a website, to learn on, it's not fair, there should be more done for the students, and a better effort, a year into now, we should be able to adapt, and have them able to do more functions on campus, and indeed, you know, have that interaction, that experience, of a six-year student going into first year, and the world is their oyster really, and they had a tough year in sixth year, the leaving starts had to be changed utterly, so the need, and the campuses, and I'm not specifically in Limerick, but all the campuses, need to do more, to be able to get out, and let the young people express themselves, let them be able to learn more, and let them be able to fulfil themselves, in spite of COVID, because it gives an opportunity as well, to deal differently, and while online learning should have been, you know, that wonderful experience, it hasn't been, it's just like throwing a website and walk away there, much more needs to be done, by the management, and the people responsible, in the universities, at third levels, to be more interactive, and engage with the students physically, as much as possible, certainly on campus, to be allowed, and not to be stuck in their rooms, on computers all day, and as I said, it's the same as giving them a website, but I'm not good.