Mattie McGrath attacks managerial bloat and hospital closures
Mattie McGrath spoke about the state of hospital services, arguing the system has far fewer beds and is burdened with non-clinical managers rather than frontline staff. He accused the Minister and hospital management of incompetence, criticised the closure of Carrickenshire Hospital, and called for permanent funding for a cancer care centre in Tipperary Town.
Claims on beds and staffing
McGrath said the system now has 6,000 fewer beds than in the 1980s and described widespread recruitment that is not translating into frontline clinical staff. He told the Minister that many new hires are not nurses or doctors but office-based roles, and warned consultants have already left and frontline services are reduced to a skeleton staff.
Managers versus frontline staff
The deputy listed numerous managerial roles - ward managers, floor managers, bed managers, linen managers, hygiene managers, food managers and discharge managers - and said there is effectively "nobody managing anything." He contrasted that with earlier hospital teams who maintained clean, sterile environments and ran services from front to back.
Criticism of hospital closures and recent failures
McGrath accused the service of incompetence after Christmas and said senior staff have resigned in disgust, arguing that hospitals are being closed unnecessarily. He singled out Carrickenshire Hospital as a shocking example, saying it was closed and left empty while ministers offered alternatives that do not address local needs.
Appeal for cancer care funding in Tipperary Town
He made an appeal for permanent funding for a new cancer care centre in Tipperary Town, praising community support and volunteers but noting limited staff and an application currently under consideration. He emphasised the centre needs stable funding to provide cancer and palliative care services.
Garbled audio at the end of the record
The transcript ends with a series of fragmented, robotic-sounding exchanges and interjections that break from the main speech and suggest an audio interruption or disturbance.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
The light of the cast I have is 6,000 fewer beds than we had in the 80s, but we have countless extra recruitment. The Minister would announce that every day all the jobs are recruitment. Where are they? They are not on the front line, they are not nurses, they are not doctors, they are inside offices and they are pin pushers. When we had the maithers run in the hospital they were impeccably clean and there were sterile environments. And they ran it from the front door to the back door and consultants have listened to them. Now we have ward managers, floor managers, bed managers, linen managers, hygiene managers, food managers, and we are floor managers, we are discharge managers, we are managers for everything. And nobody managing anything. Absolute case. What happened after Christmas, what happened again next Christmas? And she was three years sitting over there because it's just incompetence, the hospital service closed down, consultants have already disappeared, the best majority of them. There are a skeleton staff frontline who worked, might and may want to support them, but they are not getting the support. We saw one of the most senior people resign in disgust and despair two days ago, three days ago. I heard them on the radio that he could do nothing, he came with a wonderful CV, but he wasn't wanted, because he didn't get the cooperation. And it's a shocking situation. I want to appeal to, with a circular friends, a long-standing place, a cancer care centre in Tipperary Town, a new place built, fabulous support from the community and fabulous volunteers with limited staff. They need to be on a permanent funding base to deal with people for cancers and palliative care. And I have an application in at the moment and hopefully they will be successful. They need to be funded. But Ministers, and you have more Ministers too, I don't know how many years, four or five years, but you will not make much of a difference. You will not make much of a difference. And when you read out nothing short of, total diatribe to me today, Minister, but Carrickenshire Hospital, you should be ashamed to close it in your backyard and tell me this is going on, that's going on. You have a fine, big empty monstrosity. You have a white helper from the primary care centre for that going on. Not to be trying to cover your tracks here in closing a bloody good hospital is shocking. Hello. Hi, I'm beautiful. I'm very excited. I'm getting ready for my fleet a while. I have a great question, but I'm very excited. How do you expect your team to connect with the bomb? How do you expect your team to connect with them to your personal business? I'm a robot. I'm a robot. How do you expect your team to connect with them? I'm a robot. I'm a robot. You're a robot. My robot. I'm a robot. By computer. I'm a robot.
Thank you for downloading 🙏
If you publish this material on social media, we would be very grateful if you tagged VideoParliament. It helps us reach more people and keep building a transparent archive of Irish politics.
