Menu
VideoParliament
VideoParliament Irish politics in one place — download the app
Get app
VideoParliament
VideoParliament for Windows Get the desktop app — notifications about new speeches
Get app
Paul Murphy: Accuses British state of systematic collusion

Paul Murphy: Accuses British state of systematic collusion

Paul Murphy spoke in the Dáil about alleged collusion between the British state and Loyalist paramilitaries, citing the Ombudsman's report and multiple historical cases. He said the report shows systematic state policy, ongoing cover-ups, and called for prosecutions and the continuation of investigations.

Ombudsman's findings


The Ombudsman's report provides what Paul Murphy described as "black and white" evidence of collusion by the British State with Loyalist paramilitaries, including police involvement in 11 murders. He said the findings show collusion was systematic, deadly, covered up, and that those responsible have enjoyed impunity.

Documented cases cited


Murphy reviewed several specific cases cited in the report: the Sean Graham killings and the Buckee's massacre in 1992, where five people including a 15-year-old were killed and files were allegedly destroyed; the 1971 Loyalist bombing of McGurk's bar, where an admission was made that explosives had been supplied; and the 1993 killing of 17-year-old Damien Walsh, where the report found "significant investigative failures" and that information was provided to killers by a police officer and British intelligence.

Alleged state practices and cover-ups


He quoted findings that state forces handed guns to Loyalist terrorists, allowed individuals to kill with impunity while they remained useful, and deliberately failed to arrest suspects or act on intelligence. Murphy also cited judicial findings that, until late 1973, the RUC and the Army had an understanding that protected soldiers from arrest and prosecution in shootings.

Government proposals to halt inquiries


Murphy said the Prime Minister, Boris Johnson, was seeking to stop further investigations into collusion, including ending inquests ordered by the Attorney General of Northern Ireland, police ombudsman inquiries, civil actions seeking disclosure from the Ministry of Defence, and Legacy Investigation Branch work. He warned that families who had attended many preliminary hearings could now be told inquests cannot go ahead.

Paul Murphy — still from speech: Paul Murphy: Accuses British state of systematic collusion (23.02.2022)

Call for accountability over Bloody Sunday


Murphy concluded by urging prosecution of General Mike Jackson for his role in Bloody Sunday, saying Jackson organised and covered up the massacre and produced a "shot list" that fed into the Widgery report's whitewash. He argued Bloody Sunday resulted from a decision by the British establishment to suppress a civil rights movement and insisted there must be no immunity for those responsible.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.

Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →

Transcript
Thanks, Chair. Thanks a lot. What we have in black and white in the Ombudsman's report is very significant evidence and confirmation of collusion by the British State with Loyalist paramilitaries in murdering people repeatedly. The point has been made that this is far, far more than a few bad apples. It was clearly government policy, it was systematic, it was deadly and it has been covered up and it continues to be covered up and those responsible continue to have impunity. It is worth going through some of the cases, many have been mentioned, just to bring out the horror of this behaviour by a supposedly democratic state. So the report, in particular into 11 murders by Loyalist gangs, found that there was police involvement and police inclusion. Again, it should be mentioned, because people can think this is something that happened in the kind of dim and distant past, which obviously wouldn't make it okay. But we are talking about atrocities that go into the 1990s. So in relation to the Sean Graham killings, the Ombudsman found that the police colluded in the massacre at the Buckees in 1992, where five people were killed, including one 15-year-old. They found that the police deliberately destroyed files on this attack, protecting those responsible. In other cases, the RUC quite literally handed guns to Loyalist terrorists, guns that they went on to use to murder. And that's the definition of collusion, criminal conspiracy of state forces working hand in hand with terrorist gangs. State-sponsored serial killers is what the former police ombudsman called some of the police agents in Loyalist and Republican groups. Individuals were allowed to kill with impunity, so long as they remained of use to the British state. One example from 1971 is the Loyalist bombing of McGurk's bar, which killed 15 civilians and injured 17 more. Years later, a member of the covert military reaction force admitted that they had supplied the explosives, encouraged the attack, believing the bar to be a Republican hotspot. In another case, the police ombudsman highlighted the 1993 killing of Damien Walsh, a 17-year-old young man shot dead by Loyalist paramilitaries. The report found, quote, significant investigative failures, end quote, by the police amounting to, quote, collusive behaviours. It said Walsh's killers were, quote, provided with information by a police officer and British intelligence, which informed their attack, end quote. Damien's mother, Marion, had campaigned for nearly three decades, questioning the role of the police in her son's shooting. The ombudsman's report found police had also, quote, failed to capitalise on investigative opportunities, including failing to arrest suspects, and had made a deliberate decision to disregard intelligence about the threat. In another case, last year, a judge found that, quote, until late 1973, an understanding was in place between the RUC and the Army, whereby the RUC did not arrest in question or even take witness statements from soldiers involved in shootings such as this one, end quote. The judge added, this appalling practice was designed, at least in part, to protect soldiers from being prosecuted, and in very large measure, it succeeded. And now the Prime Minister of Britain, Boris Johnson, wants to stop any more investigations like this, to stop more horrors being uncovered. They're proposing to close down all investigations into the collusion between the British military and police forces and Loyalist terrorist groups. They're planning to end all inquests into killings that have been ordered by the Attorney General of Northern Ireland, as well as all investigations by the police ombudsman, even those where grave and exceptional new evidence of police misconduct has emerged. On top of that, they're seeking to end all civil actions being pursued through the courts by families seeking disclosure from the Ministry of Defence and others on evidence of collusion between state forces and paramilitaries, as well as investigations being conducted by the Legacy Investigation Branch of the Police Service of Northern Ireland, which considers historical cases of killings. This includes cases such as Soldier F, who has been charged with murders on Bloody Sunday in 1972, and the death of a man with mental disabilities killed by soldiers. The UK Government's proposals would mean families who may already have attended up to 30 preliminary hearings will now be told the inquest itself cannot go ahead. This is a cover-up, plain and simple. I want to finish with reference to another cover-up, and that is the attempt to protect General Mike Jackson from prosecution for his role in the Bloody Sunday Massacre. He was second in command of the 1st Battalion of the Parachute Regiment, and would later climb up the ladder of the British Army to become the Chief of Staff at the time of the invasion of Iraq. I was at a demonstration in Derry to mark the 50th anniversary of the murder of 14 people. Immediately after the Bloody Sunday Massacre, Jackson interviewed his soldiers and drew up a shot list of where the shootings had occurred. It was a piece of fiction, but it became the basis for the original widgery report, which whitewashed the Parachute Regiment. The mood at that protest I was at a couple of weeks ago was focused on the call for the prosecution of this man, General Sir Mike Jackson. Not only did he help to organise the massacre, but he was also the key figure in covering it up. That is why he must be brought before the courts to answer for his crimes. There is an important political point here, where the British establishment likes to portray the conflict in the North as a war between two tribes, where their army becomes supposedly piggy in the middle. But Bloody Sunday arose because of a cold-blooded decision of the British establishment to suppress a mass movement for civil rights. Correctly, you know, everybody has agreed that there must be no immunity given to the soldiers involved, but the real criminals are those who also gave the orders to shoot. Let's start by putting them in the dock. Go back and go.