Matt Shanahan on €100 Energy Rebate: Bill 'Rushed' and Inadequate
Matt Shanahan criticised the government's Electricity Costs Emergency Measures Bill, arguing a once-off €100 rebate is inadequate and poorly targeted. He warned the payment's design risks missing the most vulnerable and said the measure appears rushed and disconnected from broader energy policy.
Bill criticised
He outlined the core elements of the bill - a once-off payment of €100 to every domestic electricity supply, paid to the electricity account holder, not means-tested, and payable even to vacant holiday homes. He said the payment is not linked to energy efficiency ratings or house construction year, which he argued highlights how the bill was rushed.
Impact on vulnerable households
He identified those most affected by rising domestic energy costs - low-income and single-income families, those in substandard accommodation, pensioners on fixed incomes, the elderly and people with medical needs who require constant heating. He said a single €100 payment will not be enough to protect these groups, especially during high fuel consumption months.
Tenancy and meter concerns
He raised tenancy issues because the rebate is payable to the electricity account holder, which may mean landlords receive payments instead of tenants. He also queried how households on pay-as-you-go meters - who often face higher tariffs or debt repayments - would receive the rebate.
Causes and policy questions
He asked what has driven energy cost inflation - citing COVID, supply chain interruptions, global demand dynamics and geopolitical factors - and questioned whether past domestic policy choices contributed, including decisions on offshore gas development, reductions in coal and peat generation, and carbon levies.
Renewable strategy and infrastructure
He urged a more serious national energy and climate strategy, calling for expedited infrastructure for wind, solar and home retrofit. He noted delays such as the pending Maritime Regulation Authority and asked when the country would become a net exporter of renewable electricity or hydrogen, citing a regional motion that estimated potential investment of over €100 billion through sustainable offshore wind.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Minister, your electricity costs emergency measures bill. Basically a government initiative to soften the blow of rising energy prices. How have you framed it? A once-off payment of €100 to every domestic electricity supply in the country. It is not being means-tested, as you outlined, being too onerous for the department, I think you said to consider. As well as being paid to domestically occupied houses, the proposal is to pay it to vacant holiday homes also, where one presumes the consumption of electricity will be very reduced with no occupancy. It will also be paid to the electricity account holder, which raises obvious questions in tenancy arrangements, where the landlord is receiving the rebate. I know you said you are hoping to engage, I think, with the Rental Tenancies Board Minister. I think you know the significant difficulties already in that sector. I do not know how that is going to work. Your proposal, Minister, has no relationship to the energy efficiency rating of a house, or to the year of a house construction, which might point to some properties of superior energy efficiency, and therefore allowed some reducing stage payment. I think that shows how the bill is being rushed in the first place. Within the legislation, the measures, it appears, are to provide one month's help to families or individuals who actually incur 12 months of annual energy and electricity bills. Who is the most affected minister by rising domestic energy costs? Well, certainly low-income families, single-income families, certainly those in substandard accommodation paying to eat it. Those on fixed payment means, particularly pensioners, who were on fixed pensions from many years ago. The elderly and those who require constant home eating, such as those who are informed, those with potential illness. So those on blood-thinning medications, for example, who will always feel constantly cold and require central heating to be on all the time. In your legislation, Minister, did you consider the position, the rebate position, of those who are on a pay-to-go electricity meter? And many of these are already paying a higher tariff, as you know. Firstly, because they are paying through a meter. And secondly, they are often paying back on a previous electricity bill. How are they to receive their rebate? And what is the basis, Minister, I would ask you for this energy cost inflation? Is it COVID, supply chain interruptions, Russian tanks massing, OPEC oil rationing, megaphone politicking, threatening gas supplies to Europe? Or is it the re-emergence of global energy demand? And I think, Minister, these are all parts of the problem. But I wonder too, in Ireland, I would ask you the question, have we contributed to this domestic energy crisis? When we decided to dispense with any more offshore gas development without considering viable alternatives, Minister, could this be a factor? When we decided to reduce coal and peat burning electricity generation, again without viable alternatives, could this also be a factor? When we placed a carbon levy on fossil fuels, do we think that nobody would notice in the population an increase in their cost of consumption and the cost of living would plainly follow? Did we think that when we applied additional cost to the existing cost of production, that they would not be seen in every utility bill and every shopping centre receipt in the country within weeks? Did economics lesson 101, Minister, get missed by everyone in your department framing climate and energy policy? I believe, and I'm sure, members among my regional group, members believe, Minister, that this single proposed initiative will not be enough to protect some of the most vulnerable in our society, and that more will need to be done to support these families over the coming months, but most especially during the high fuel consumption months. But I think, Minister, it also creates a wider debate about the nature of Ireland's developing national energy and climate policy. We are talking about wind, we are talking about solar generation, but where is it, Minister? The Maritime Regulation Authority is two years yet away from being set up, and we need that in order to control the development of the maritime space. How long, Minister, do you think before Ireland will become a net exporter of renewable electricity? How long even before we become a net exporter of hydrogen fuel? How long before we fit and retrofit homes to a high energy standard and allow domestic generation of electricity through wind arrays and solar arrays? Because, Minister, we are far from there as yet. How long do we intend to remain completely dependent on the supply of international energy when we have billions in potential capacity sitting off our shores in untapped gas and wind energy? But we seem strategically unable to develop this. Instead, we are asking foreign conglomerates to come into this country to buy the rights and then to quote a Disney movie to charge us into infinity and beyond for the pleasure of consuming our own resources, Minister. We in the regional group, Minister, brought to government some months back a new wind energy motion which was accepted by the House. And some of the pieces within that bill suggest the potential that exists within solar, wind and gas generation in the country. And particularly an investment potentially of over €100 billion into our economy through the generation of sustainable offshore wind, Minister. Minister, I think the time has come now that we need to get serious about climate. We have done the talk and we have decided to get the population on board by telling that we are charging them for what we are consuming. But what we are not doing, Minister, absolutely failing to do at this moment in time, is put in real meaningful policy and change to generate and expedite the infrastructure development that is required in this country. And when we look around at what is going on in Portugal, what is going on in Spain, what is going on in Germany, what is going on in Denmark, Minister, how can we be so far behind at this stage? And what is the delay in getting all of these policies rolled out? So, Minister, as I say, I cannot say I welcome this bill because it is unwelcome in the fact of the need that it is addressing. As I said to you, I think we will have to do more to protect vulnerable families. And I wait to hear, Minister, what policies you will roll out. But most importantly, the only way that we will get to creating any disruption to future energy supplies is to have our own Minister. That means we need to develop our own resources. We need to get about it. Thank you. Thank you. Yes, thank you to colour. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. You're right. Star Wars. Panarré. Harry Margaret Van Der Ba Àtk.
Thank you for downloading 🙏
If you publish this material on social media, we would be very grateful if you tagged VideoParliament. It helps us reach more people and keep building a transparent archive of Irish politics.
