Ruth Coppinger: Sinn Féin's Shift to the Right on Abortion Bill
Ruth Coppinger speaks in the Dáil about attempts to roll back abortion rights eight years after repeal, criticising legal distinctions and recent party moves. She accuses some politicians and Sinn Féin of pushing a conservative agenda that threatens bodily autonomy and calls for decriminalisation to protect women and doctors.
Ruth Coppinger recalls the grassroots victory eight years ago that secured bodily autonomy for women. She warns that current Dáil discussions and legal manoeuvres risk rolling back those gains, singling out party tactics and what she describes as cynical compromises made to secure votes.
Coppinger disputes the distinction between fatal and severe foetal abnormality, calling it unscientific and unnecessary. She argues the wording was a concession to conservative politicians and should not be used as grounds to oppose decriminalisation or restrict access.
She directly criticises individual politicians and Sinn Féin for what she terms a rightward shift and for introducing a three-day wait proposal. Coppinger frames these moves as responses to pressure from the far right, saying women's rights are being sacrificed for political calculation.
Coppinger explains that decriminalisation prevents women from being criminalised for taking abortion medication and removes the chilling effect that stops doctors from acting to save lives. She stresses that criminal law currently forces some women to travel or be sent abroad because of medical uncertainty.
The speech ends with a demand for accountability and pressure on parties to change course. Coppinger urges citizens and colleagues to recognise where parties stand on abortion rights and to act to defend them.
Historical context and vote dynamics
Ruth Coppinger recalls the grassroots victory eight years ago that secured bodily autonomy for women. She warns that current Dáil discussions and legal manoeuvres risk rolling back those gains, singling out party tactics and what she describes as cynical compromises made to secure votes.
The debate over fetal abnormality rules
Coppinger disputes the distinction between fatal and severe foetal abnormality, calling it unscientific and unnecessary. She argues the wording was a concession to conservative politicians and should not be used as grounds to oppose decriminalisation or restrict access.
Accusations against parties and politicians
She directly criticises individual politicians and Sinn Féin for what she terms a rightward shift and for introducing a three-day wait proposal. Coppinger frames these moves as responses to pressure from the far right, saying women's rights are being sacrificed for political calculation.
Why decriminalisation matters
Coppinger explains that decriminalisation prevents women from being criminalised for taking abortion medication and removes the chilling effect that stops doctors from acting to save lives. She stresses that criminal law currently forces some women to travel or be sent abroad because of medical uncertainty.
A call to action
The speech ends with a demand for accountability and pressure on parties to change course. Coppinger urges citizens and colleagues to recognise where parties stand on abortion rights and to act to defend them.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Mary Lou McDonald
Mary Lou McDonald: Taoiseach Must End Ambulance Crisis Now
Danny Healy-Rae
Danny Healy-Rae backs bill to fast-track rural infrastructure
Richard Boyd Barrett
Richard Boyd Barrett: Calls Abortion Criminalisation 'Disgrace'
Jack Chambers
Jack Chambers: Defends removing Section 15 to speed projects
Brian Brennan
Brian Brennan on Wind Turbine Regulation Bill 2025: Villages at Risk
Carol Nolan
Carol Nolan: Cameras Welcome, Footpaths Needed Now
Transcript
So, eight years ago, we were pounding pavements, having thousands of conversations, and we won the most important right to bodily autonomy for women in this country, in history, with a grassroots movement. Now, some people seem to think that they can roll back that right. I think we're seeing signs of this even in the Dáil today in some of the discussions. I want to talk about what the government have said about legal nuances. Travelling for fatal foetal abnormality. There never should have been a distinction between fatal foetal abnormality and severe foetal abnormality in the first place. There isn't in any other country. It's unscientific, because doctors cannot, you know, with surety predict. But in other countries, it's just abnormalities. But because of cowardly and conservative politicians and to get Simon Coveney and others to agree to vote for repeal, it was put in there. And it's still not a reason to vote against the bill. So, let's be clear. Parties opposing this tonight, and politicians individually, you favour forced birth, because you're basically saying that anyone who's pregnant, outside of the strict criteria that exist, should just be forced to continue that. But also, you have the safety valve of the UK and other countries. And, you know, I was very disappointed, not a bit surprised, to be honest, to hear David Cullen and Ann saying he doesn't agree. It was actually, who cares if you don't agree? This should not be your decision to tell a pregnant woman what to do with her life and with her situation. And I found it very arrogant of you to stand there and say that. I wasn't surprised because I saw Sinn Féin rushing through a bill here last Thursday on a three-day wait. I had a bill under the three-day wait. It's great that Sinn Féin have one eight years after repeal. But I knew you were doing it. I was fearing you weren't, but my cynicism proved correct to not vote for this bill tonight. You know, you'd say, oh, we have our bill and we don't need to vote for this bill. It's cynical. It's conservative. It's a ship to the right by Sinn Féin because you supported Breed Smith's bill here in the last Dáil and now you're responding, I think, to the far right, to other individuals who gave you criticism on the vote recently and now you're circling the wagons and women's rights have to pay the price. You know, it really is shocking, but it's good to bring clarity for people as to where parties stand. So decriminalising, let's be clear, is to prevent women being criminalised as well for taking an abortion pill after 12 weeks or whatever in their bedroom. But also it's to get rid of the chilling effect which prevents doctors from acting to save lives and to save health. And also it's forcing doctors to send women abroad with abnormalities because they're not deadly sure. That's why it's decriminalising. Stop pretending that you're protecting women and really that nonsense where you try to say that it was because of that. So yeah, very disappointing to hear Sinn Féin are going to basically scopre this bill tonight. We have to put pressure on them to change tack.