Brian Stanley: Calls Israel a 'terrorist state', urges ostracism
Brian Stanley addressed the Dáil during a Social Democrats motion on sport and international engagement, arguing that Israel should be ostracised over its conduct in Gaza and the occupied territories. He urged government, broadcasters and sporting bodies to take stronger measures in response to the humanitarian crisis and alleged war crimes.
Brian Stanley told the Minister that while sport matters, there are things more important than football. He described the killings in Gaza and the West Bank as genocide and called on Ireland and international bodies to treat Israel as a terrorist state until it makes amends.
Stanley cited casualty figures and the ongoing humanitarian impact, noting over 75,000 deaths in Gaza since 2023 October 23 and further deaths and injuries since the October 25 ceasefire. He referenced medics, journalists, families and children killed, the strangulation of normal life in the West Bank, and the expansion of violence into southern Lebanon.
He criticised sporting bodies and broadcasters for not acting sooner, comparing the situation to previous bans on Russia and Yugoslavia and to the anti-apartheid boycott of South African goods. He welcomed RTE's Eurovision boycott and the government ban on two Israeli ministers, and urged UEFA, FIFA and others to suspend Israeli participation.
Stanley framed the issue as moral and political, asking whether supporters of Israeli policy share blame for its actions. He argued that Irish public opinion now supports stronger measures and that boycott and ostracism could send a powerful international message until the violence stops.
Summary of remarks
Brian Stanley told the Minister that while sport matters, there are things more important than football. He described the killings in Gaza and the West Bank as genocide and called on Ireland and international bodies to treat Israel as a terrorist state until it makes amends.
Human cost and evidence cited
Stanley cited casualty figures and the ongoing humanitarian impact, noting over 75,000 deaths in Gaza since 2023 October 23 and further deaths and injuries since the October 25 ceasefire. He referenced medics, journalists, families and children killed, the strangulation of normal life in the West Bank, and the expansion of violence into southern Lebanon.
Sporting and cultural sanctions
He criticised sporting bodies and broadcasters for not acting sooner, comparing the situation to previous bans on Russia and Yugoslavia and to the anti-apartheid boycott of South African goods. He welcomed RTE's Eurovision boycott and the government ban on two Israeli ministers, and urged UEFA, FIFA and others to suspend Israeli participation.
Political and moral consequences
Stanley framed the issue as moral and political, asking whether supporters of Israeli policy share blame for its actions. He argued that Irish public opinion now supports stronger measures and that boycott and ostracism could send a powerful international message until the violence stops.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Brian Stanley presses government over 15-year wind delay
Brian Stanley warns of soaring private health insurance costs
Brian Stanley: Fury over plan to abolish the triple lock
Brian Stanley Presses on UN Mandate and 'Triple Lock' Referendum
Brian Stanley challenges defence on undersea infrastructure protection
Brian Stanley: County Laois left without rural EV chargers
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Mattie McGrath
Mattie McGrath: Ban Dangerous Sulky Racing on Public Roads
Gerard P. Craughwell
Gerard P. Craughwell presses cyber chief on SME support
Rose Conway-Walsh
Rose Conway-Walsh: Occupied Territories Bill Fails to Include Services
Gerard P. Craughwell
Gerard P. Craughwell: Bill is Populist and Unworkable
Ruth Coppinger
Ruth Coppinger: Calls out handling of counselling notes
Albert Dolan
Albert Dolan: Protect Rural Short-Term Lets and Galway Castle
Transcript
Thanks Cathaoirleach, and I want to thank the Social Dems for bringing forward this comprehensive motion. Can I say to you Minister that football is very very important, and I certainly don't want to be stopping any sport, but there are other things that actually are more important, and the slaughter that we've witnessed in Palestine, not just in the last two to three years, but going back over generations, that's important that that's stopped. The fact that medics are being killed, journalists, families, children, absolute genocide, the strangulation of normal life in the West Bank, the ethnic cleansing of the West Bank, and now Lebanon, all of southern Lebanon, almost a quarter of the territory. It's war crimes, and people in Israel who support it are as guilty as their government. And I don't care what religion anybody is, whether they're Jewish, Catholic, Protestant, whatever it is, I'm not interested. That's not the issue here. The issue is here, do you support the genocide of your government? And people in Israel that do, share some of this blame. A lot of Israeli people don't support it, and a lot of Jews don't support it, that I've met, and that's good. But over 75,000 people have died in Gaza since 2023, October 23. Along with the aerial bombardments, starvation, disease, people buried under rubble, it's horrendous what people have seen. And since the October 25 ceasefire, 947 Palestinians have been killed and over 3,000 injured. And to rub salt into the wounds, the treatment of the flotilla, including the 13 Irish citizens, was fingers up to the international community. Israel is not a normal state, Israel is a terrorist state, and should be treated as such. And FIFA and UEFA, when it came to Russia, there's been international bans on Yugoslavia as well. But what's wrong? It's the same thing as what's happening, what Israel has done to Palestinians, is that not the same? And I note the fact that well over 90% of the FAI members voted to instruct the association to call on UEFA to suspend Israel, and that should have happened. There's grown support across the country for the match not to go ahead. And ordinary people who normally wouldn't get to think too much about politics or what's going on in the world, the number of people that have spoken to me in the last couple of years who are horrified by what they're seeing, and the good work that's been done by journalists, those who have been left alive to actually witness it in Gaza, that have brought that information to us on a daily basis, people are horrified with it. And you may say that it's tokenistic or whatever, but when the girls and the women in Dunn stores back in 1984, when they took the small step of not handling South African fruit, it mushroomed and ballooned out into the boycott of the apartheid regime. And this has the potential to do the same thing. We must send a powerful message to Israel, the Israeli government, and to the Israeli people who support them. It's not acceptable, they're genocide. And as I said, there are some things more important than sport. And Irish people want action, and here's the opportunity. I want to welcome the measure taken by RTE to boycott the Eurovision, I think that was good. I welcome the measure by the government to ban the two ministers, the security minister and the finance minister. But go further, go further than that. Israel needs to be ostracised in total until they make amends for what they've done to the Palestinian people. For more UN videos visit www.un.org