Brian Stanley: Calls for Rent Caps and Windfall Tax
Brian Stanley addresses rising cost of living and urges immediate measures to protect low and middle income households. He calls for reinstating rent caps, a windfall tax on large energy firms, extended medical card coverage and value for taxpayers' money.
Brian Stanley outlines how rents, mortgages, energy, motor fuel, food and health insurance have risen in double digits while wages have stagnated. He blames the removal of rent pressure zones by Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael for soaring rents and highlights examples of extreme local increases.
He raises concerns about cost overruns and wasted public money in state projects, IT systems that fail, and inconsistent school build prices under Department of Education framework agreements. Stanley urges the Department to re-examine these frameworks to secure better value for taxpayers.
Stanley proposes short-term measures: extend medical card cover until the promised public health system is in place, impose a windfall tax on large energy companies to fund retrofitting for middle-income households, and increase the minimum wage to a living wage.
He demands the reintroduction of county rent caps, faster rollout of solar and retrofit schemes, and reform or replacement of the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission, which he calls ineffective. He warns that middle-income workers cannot be ignored in this year's tax decisions.
Cost of living crisis
Brian Stanley outlines how rents, mortgages, energy, motor fuel, food and health insurance have risen in double digits while wages have stagnated. He blames the removal of rent pressure zones by Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael for soaring rents and highlights examples of extreme local increases.
Public spending and procurement
He raises concerns about cost overruns and wasted public money in state projects, IT systems that fail, and inconsistent school build prices under Department of Education framework agreements. Stanley urges the Department to re-examine these frameworks to secure better value for taxpayers.
Immediate policy proposals
Stanley proposes short-term measures: extend medical card cover until the promised public health system is in place, impose a windfall tax on large energy companies to fund retrofitting for middle-income households, and increase the minimum wage to a living wage.
Housing and consumer protection
He demands the reintroduction of county rent caps, faster rollout of solar and retrofit schemes, and reform or replacement of the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission, which he calls ineffective. He warns that middle-income workers cannot be ignored in this year's tax decisions.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Brian Stanley: Warns of GP Shortage and Pressure on A&E
Brian Stanley questions Irish Water over £27,000 rural connection
Brian Stanley: Urgent GP shortage risks rural primary care
Brian Stanley: Will Water Funding Follow Rezoning?
Brian Stanley urges urgent regulation of social media algorithms
Brian Stanley: Halt the Defence Amendment Bill, Defend Neutrality
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Pearse Doherty
Pearse Doherty: Government fuel and electricity hikes are reckless
Richard O'Donoghue
Richard O'Donoghue: 'You're Not Learning' on Carbon Tax
Victor Boyhan
Victor Boyhan: R&D and Certification Are the Key Barriers
Simon Harris
Simon Harris: Ireland's Presidency Pledge, Backing Ukraine
Gerard P. Craughwell
Gerard P. Craughwell praises public servants as EU presidency begins
Mairéad Farrell
Mairéad Farrell: Galway rents up 18% - Government must act
Transcript
Sir Marcus, Minister, the cost of living is rising at an alarming rate. Right across the board, middle and low income households cannot keep up, particularly households on below £75,000. Those on £650,000, £60,000 and £70,000 used to be counted as being well off. They're not now. Rents, mortgages, electricity, gas, motor fuel, food, health insurance and much more, they've all increased, not in single figures, but double digit figures on every hike. Meanwhile, wages and incomes increased by 1 or 2% or not at all. And in the case of housing, rents are skyrocketing due to Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael's decision to remove the rent pressure zones. However meek they were, and a lot of us on this side of the house wanted them nailed down tighter, the facts are that the removal of them means that double digit figures are what is happening. And a two bedroom unit in County Leash has gone up by 34% in one year, the rent is. 34%, that's the increase. Mortgage repayments are now higher because the overall capital sum being borrowed to keep up with Gallup and house prices is increasing. And in the case of Leash again, 12, 13, 14% of an increase in one year. Electricity and gas, they're increasing today, 8%. On top of all the recent increases, home heat and oil, up 50-60%. Motor fuels have increased. And where do you leave health insurance? We'd better not forget about that. Health insurance, which families and households and individuals are forced to get because we haven't got the slaunch care yet, that's gone up two and three times a year. Huge increases, 6, 7, 8, 9% in each time. At the same time, public money is being wasted. Government and state projects have costs overruns and that needs to be curtailed. Value for taxpayers' money. I will always argue for money for projects, but we have to get value for taxpayers' money. IT systems that don't work. Construction projects that finish up double the cost of their budget. Layers upon layers of management and bureaucracy in public bodies that should be rationalised and streamlined. And all of this and much more needs to be history. And can I just give you one example? In relation to school projects, extensions for schools, the Department of Education has framework agreements for those. I'll give you one example of a two-classroom unit, ASD with an all-timber outside finish. £2.7 million. One 30 or 40 miles away, which I can show you and I brought to the attention of the Department today, £2.05 million. It's completed in brick. It's a bigger unit, has the ancillary rooms and has everything else in it. So these framework agreements need to be re-examined. I hope, Minister, you're listening to what I'm saying to you because this is an important issue, and the senior officials, and this is brought to the attention of the Department of Education. These framework agreements, I'm saying this in a serious way, need to be looked at. So what do we need to do? There's a whole lot of things to be done, but a couple of immediate things we need to do is to extend medical card cover until we get the slauncher care. Slauncher care, the public health system, which it's envisaged in it, that has to be prioritised. Short term, we need to extend medical card cover to ordinary workers and families who can't go to doctors and get medical treatment because they can't afford to. And that will help all those people who don't have medical cards but can't afford health insurance. We need to bring in a windfall tax to be imposed on the large energy companies, including the windfarm owners, where there are high profits. Once profits go over a certain amount, that money should be used and ploughed into retrofitting for middle income families who don't qualify for the free scheme, and on the other hand, they can't afford to match the funding for the other schemes. I'm saying that to you, there's an opportunity here. The people in the middle are caught. If you're on social welfare, and rightly so, you get the free scheme, if you're on fuel allowance. If you're on over, people who are under 75,000 generally, they're caught because they can't afford the retrofitting or the electric car. The minimum wage needs to be increased to a living wage. We need to reintroduce the rent caps for each county. We need to speed up the solar and retrofitting of households. And we need to scrap the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission as it stands, or else reform it. Because in my time here, I've heard it and I've seen reports of it, and it's a toothless tiger. It's turned out to be useless. And what I would say to you is that last year, there was £9.5 billion in excess that was given out, and nothing happened to workers, nothing happened to taxation. For those middle income workers, those people on between £20,000 and £70,000, they got nothing, zero. So this year, don't forget about them. Adjust the tax plans to favour those low and middle income workers. Don't miss the opportunity this year again.