Mattie McGrath: Calls Garda Numbers 'Manicured', Rural Crisis
Mattie McGrath criticised Garda staffing levels and local policing, saying official numbers had been "manicured" and that communities are losing officers. He highlighted shortages in Timplemore, Tipperary, Carrick, Shure and named Conmel District, Mulderhorn, Kitchean and Cachillacare as areas affected, and urged more Gardaí on the streets.
McGrath opened by saying the published Garda numbers had been "manicured" and that "we're just not getting the numbers." He warned the situation will deteriorate as personnel leave the force and said historical figures showed the need for better planning.
He cited specific local impacts: Carrick and Shure now have "three Gardaí now and two Souths," compared with where they used to have 14 Gardaí. He said Conmel District covers Carrick and Shure, Mulderhorn covers that area, and Kitchean covers Cachillacare and surrounding villages.
McGrath quoted a superintendent who, he said, can have eight Gardaí "on a good day," underlining the limited operational capacity locally. He argued these reduced numbers undermine policing in rural communities.
While acknowledging Gardaí are engaging with communities, including recent outreach to Muslims and travellers, McGrath said such work "isn't going to help in the immediate time." He concluded by pressing for an increase in frontline Gardaí, saying more officers are needed on the streets to address the problem.
Staffing figures criticised
McGrath opened by saying the published Garda numbers had been "manicured" and that "we're just not getting the numbers." He warned the situation will deteriorate as personnel leave the force and said historical figures showed the need for better planning.
Local station shortages
He cited specific local impacts: Carrick and Shure now have "three Gardaí now and two Souths," compared with where they used to have 14 Gardaí. He said Conmel District covers Carrick and Shure, Mulderhorn covers that area, and Kitchean covers Cachillacare and surrounding villages.
On-the-ground capacity
McGrath quoted a superintendent who, he said, can have eight Gardaí "on a good day," underlining the limited operational capacity locally. He argued these reduced numbers undermine policing in rural communities.
Community engagement and call for more officers
While acknowledging Gardaí are engaging with communities, including recent outreach to Muslims and travellers, McGrath said such work "isn't going to help in the immediate time." He concluded by pressing for an increase in frontline Gardaí, saying more officers are needed on the streets to address the problem.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Deputy Mattie McGrath - speech from 12 Dec 2019
Mattie McGrath warns on school transport, special needs, class sizes
Mattie McGrath Blasts Energy Firms and Warns of Pipeline Sabotage
Mattie McGrath urges wage subsidy for childcare owner-managers
Mattie McGrath Questions 2050 Climate Neutrality for Farmers
Mattie McGrath Defends Speaking Order, Calls for 'Lie' Withdrawal
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Paul Murphy
Paul Murphy challenges government on alleged unnecessary hip surgeries
Richard O'Donoghue
Richard O'Donoghue urges ministers to be accountable
Rose Conway-Walsh
Rose Conway-Walsh: Denounces 'Staggering' Government Financial Waste
Michael Collins
Michael Collins demands Department of Efficiency over waste
Michael Fitzmaurice
Michael Fitzmaurice: Demands oversight and value-for-money in housing
Paul Murphy
Paul Murphy criticises €50m Gaeltacht plan, raises Airbnb alarm
Transcript
This is a huge issue. I welcome the statements, but the numbers have been manicured. We're just not getting the numbers. We want to keep Timplemore because it's a wonderful centre there. But it takes out Tipperary. Carrick and Shure have three Gardaí now and two Souths. It's where they used to have 14 Gardaí. Conmel District, which covers Carrick and Shure, Mulderhorn covers that, Kitchean covers Cachillacare and all the villages. On a good day, the superintendent tells me he will have eight Gardaí. Do you tell me the Kremlins don't know this? They're over in gangs. It's a shocking situation and it's only going to deteriorate with the amount of people that are due to leave the Gardaí. And those figures are there when they came in for 30 years. They know. So they haven't planned for this. And to see Gardaí then addressing the Muslims lately to make him in, travellers, anybody else, they really are doing their best. But it's not going to help in the immediate time. We need to get more Gardaí on the streets. Thank you.