Paul Murphy condemns 'performative cruelty' in migration policy
Paul Murphy criticised recent shifts in migration policy, warning of a "race to the bottom" across Europe and saying Ireland is moving to mirror a Danish-style asylum system. He argued that the changes - influenced by Nigel Farage and echoed by the minister - will restrict family reunification and inflict unnecessary cruelty on refugees.
Paul Murphy said the emerging approach to asylum across the EU and Europe is a downward spiral, describing it as a race to the bottom. He accused political figures of driving policy toward harsher controls rather than addressing underlying social needs.
He referenced a recent UK announcement to implement a Danish-style asylum system and noted an immediate response from the minister, who said Ireland would monitor the UK changes and make appropriate adjustments. Murphy warned this dynamic means external actors are effectively shaping Ireland's migration policy.
Murphy focused on proposed restrictions that would make it harder for refugees who have been granted status to reunite with partners and children. He described the measures as "horrifically cruel" and said they contradict the recognition that these people cannot safely return to their countries.
He pointed to rulings against Denmark - including a European Court of Human Rights finding on the right to family life and an accusation of racial discrimination by the European Court of Justice - as evidence of the harms of such policies. Murphy also said refugees report that integration feels pointless under these conditions.
Beyond human rights concerns, Murphy argued the policies are performative cruelty that do not build houses or improve public services and will have political fallout. He cited recent electoral losses for the Social Democrats as an example of where such a strategy can lead.
Policy critique
Paul Murphy said the emerging approach to asylum across the EU and Europe is a downward spiral, describing it as a race to the bottom. He accused political figures of driving policy toward harsher controls rather than addressing underlying social needs.
Reaction to UK and ministerial statement
He referenced a recent UK announcement to implement a Danish-style asylum system and noted an immediate response from the minister, who said Ireland would monitor the UK changes and make appropriate adjustments. Murphy warned this dynamic means external actors are effectively shaping Ireland's migration policy.
Family reunification and refugee rights
Murphy focused on proposed restrictions that would make it harder for refugees who have been granted status to reunite with partners and children. He described the measures as "horrifically cruel" and said they contradict the recognition that these people cannot safely return to their countries.
Legal findings and Danish example
He pointed to rulings against Denmark - including a European Court of Human Rights finding on the right to family life and an accusation of racial discrimination by the European Court of Justice - as evidence of the harms of such policies. Murphy also said refugees report that integration feels pointless under these conditions.
Political consequences and practical objections
Beyond human rights concerns, Murphy argued the policies are performative cruelty that do not build houses or improve public services and will have political fallout. He cited recent electoral losses for the Social Democrats as an example of where such a strategy can lead.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Other speeches
Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →
Danny Healy-Rae
Danny Healy-Rae – Committee (19.11.25)
Victor Boyhan
Victor Boyhan warns of teacher shortages, urges action on rural housing
Brian Stanley
Brian Stanley demands immediate passage of Occupied Territories Bill
Eoghan Kenny
Eoghan Kenny details expansion of health and veterinary student places
Victor Boyhan
Victor Boyhan urges stronger powers for food regulator
Richard Boyd Barrett
Richard Boyd Barrett demands passage of Occupied Territories Bill
Transcript
Thanks. I want to speak about the race to the bottom in migration policy that is happening right across the European Union and Europe. We saw it unfold over the last few days, whereby the British government announced that they were going to implement a Danish-style asylum system, cracking down further on already very limited rights of people to asylum, dancing to the tune of Nigel Farage. That was immediately followed by a statement from Minister Jim O'Callaghan, who said that he is aware of these changes in the UK and committed to ensuring that Ireland is not viewed more favourably and will monitor the changes in the UK and make appropriate changes here. We have reached a situation where, effectively, Nigel Farage is writing Irish migration policy. Because Nigel Farage calls for something, the Labour Party jumps in Britain and now Jim O'Callaghan jumps after that. It is absolutely disgusting. It is a policy that is marked by performative cruelty. In other words, cruelty does not make life any better for any ordinary person in this country, does not build one more house, does not make one more house available, does not deal with our crisis in public services or anything else. It just makes life harder for some of the most vulnerable people. At the centre of what the government is saying, one of the changes they are talking about, after talking about a firm but fair system, they are talking about making it harder for refugees to reunite with their families. These are refugees who have been granted, they have gone through the asylum process, they have been granted refugee status and so they are recognised that it is not safe for them to go home to a country like Afghanistan. The government is now saying that even though we say it is not safe for them, we are not going to allow their children to come and join them, they are not allowed their partner to come and join them, even though clearly they are very unlikely to be safe either. It is a horrifically cruel policy and you should look at what is happening in Denmark which is inspiring all this stuff. The reality is the European Court of Human Rights has found that Denmark violated the right to family life under the ECHR, the European Court of Justice accused Denmark of racial discrimination, refugees have spoken about feeling that integration is pointless because they are effectively not allowed to integrate. I do not suspect you care about any of that, but maybe look at the election results. Social Democrats just took a hammering because people who oppose racism voted for parties to their left and have lost control of Copenhagen as a result of parties to their left and those who have legitimised have lost other voters to their right. You may not listen to the basic cause of humanity, but maybe look at politically where this leads for you. Thank you Deputy. I know that you are going to be a bit more of what you've taken from your right now. Thank you. Thank you Deputy. I have been having some questions to my left. Thank you Deputy. I am pleased to think that you have any questions and questions around the screen. I am going to be a moment of a knock out of your left and you think that you may understand what's happening in your left hand. You are going to be a hand. Let me see. I want to walk you back to your left hand. You know that you are going to be an