Menu
VideoParliament
VideoParliament Irish politics in one place — download the app
Get app
VideoParliament
VideoParliament for Windows Get the desktop app — notifications about new speeches
Get app
Mattie McGrath warns on e-scooter safety and tax exemptions

Mattie McGrath warns on e-scooter safety and tax exemptions

Deputy Mattie McGrath spoke on 16 Oct 2019 about the legal treatment of electric scooters and electric bicycles, arguing for fairness and stronger safety measures. He opposed removing tax and insurance requirements and called for clearer road traffic rules, age limits, taillights and further investigation.

Speech overview


Deputy Mattie McGrath outlined concerns about a bill that would change the legal definition of mechanically propelled vehicles and affect the treatment of electric scooters and electric bicycles.

Legal change proposed


He said the bill would remove requirements for electronic scooters and electric bicycles to be taxed and insured by altering the definition of mechanically propelled vehicles, a change he questioned for fairness with other road users and vehicles.

Road safety concerns


McGrath highlighted safety risks from small tyres and higher speeds - noting some scooters can reach 25-40 kph - and said existing measures around drug testing and enforcement were not clear. He referred to current seizure powers by GRD and raised questions about age limits and the need for visible taillights.

Youth innovation and safety technology


He pointed to work by Jason Maher and a tyre app he produced, saying such innovations, supported by the Road Safety Authority and insurers, could cut serious accidents and fatalities and should be considered in policy discussions.

Mattie McGrath — frame from remarks: Mattie McGrath warns on e-scooter safety and tax exemptions (16.10.2019)

Criticism of the minister and call for further investigation


The deputy criticised the minister’s public promotion of electric cars as hypocritical and called for more detailed investigation of the bill. He urged that road safety, visibility, testing and consistent rules across urban and rural areas be addressed before changes proceed.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.

Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →

Transcript
As Deputy McSherley indicated when he initiated this bill at first stage, the purpose here was to set legal parameters for the safe use of electric scooters. Currently it is effectively illegal to use an electric scooter on Irish roads and such vehicles are liable for seizure by GRD. There is also a requirement that these vehicles be taxed and insured as mechanically propelled vehicles. And let's face it, every other vehicle has to be, so why should they be exempt? As I understand it, the bill removes the requirements for electronic scooters and electric bicycles to be taxed and insured by altering the definition of mechanically propelled vehicles. I would have major concerns here on the fairness to other, we must be fair to everybody. I don't see anywhere where the road traffic amendment bill regarding revitalising or drug testing for these vehicles. I don't know, is it the bill, or what's the story, or are we going to have one law for Dublin and a different law for the country, because the scooters won't be used in Tipperary, you know, or Cork. Yes, the scooters cannot travel at high speed, but they are capable of getting up to 25 to 30 kph, even 40 kph in some of the more expensive varieties. And that is at high speed if you run into somebody's ability to stop, and that is because of tiny tyres. And indeed, I want to see where I have a young man in care, Jason Maher, who has a tyre app produced, the finest app you could have, and it's a road safety authority, our insurance companies embrace it. We would cut down on multiple serious accidents, and indeed fatalities. And he's put some ideas into it, and we must think outside the box and listen to young men like him when they have researched this and have done a tremendous work on it. I see a clear reason why scooters should be exempt from tax. We know that road safety campaigns in housing estates require the speed to be kept under 20 kph, and they should be. We introduced Jake's law some years ago regarding the cars. This is a clear recognition that mechanically propelled devices are capable of harm and should be used with care and distinction. And I don't know, as I mentioned either, but the age of use, can a child drive them? Which I often see, unfortunately, is there an age limit? The fact that this method of travel, especially in cities, is increasing, only serves to highlight the greater necessity to treat them as we do other methods of mechanically travelling. And maybe Minister Ross, instead of his electric car that he plugged in outside in wherever his village is, and there was nothing there. They're only a fake. Fake news, fake minister, fake green emissions. A total fake and a fraud. Tell her you have to come in here every evening to replace them. I think we'll have to get an effigy of him made and put it over there in the seat at night time, that we won't forget what he looks like. So, I wish this bill more investigation. And another thing I want to see is taillights are luminous. They're very dangerous in the dark, and you don't see these vehicles. There's a lot of issues around this area. .