Brendan Smith urges full public inquiry into murder and collusion
Brendan Smith called for a full public inquiry into the murder and alleged collusion, endorsing Senator O'Donnell's motion and expressing support for the bereaved family's campaign. He urged that the Oireachtas' position be communicated to the Office of the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland ahead of a decision due before the end of the month.
Call for a full public inquiry
Brendan Smith, speaking on behalf of the Fianna Fáil party, insisted there must be a full public inquiry and formally endorsed Senator O'Donnell's motion. He reiterated that successive governments had reaffirmed this position since the Weston Park agreement in 2001 and said the British government should honour its commitments.
Support for the family
He complimented John on presenting the case with clarity and composure and praised the dignity and courage of John and his mother throughout their long campaign. He recalled the Taoiseach's meeting with the family and the pledge that the full weight of the Taoiseach's office would be behind their quest for a full public inquiry.
Oireachtas and Secretary of State engagement
Brendan Smith called for the deliberations and outcome of the Oireachtas meeting to be conveyed to the Office of the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland. He noted the Secretary of State had indicated a decision would be made before the end of the month and said Oireachtas bodies, including plenary sessions and committees, should press for the inquiry.
Legacy cases and access to records
He referenced wider legacy issues, including appeals for access to papers relating to the Dublin Monaghan bombings and other atrocities. Brendan Smith spoke of collusion and state involvement in past atrocities in his own constituency in Cavernman and across Northern Ireland, and insisted the truth must be paramount in resolving these matters.
Urgency and expectations
He expressed the hope that the campaign for a full public inquiry would reach a successful outcome within days and lamented that the issue remains unresolved some 31 years after the murder and long after the Weston Park agreement.
We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.
Thank you very much, I can hear it again. Firstly, could I just compliment John on presenting the case with such clarity and with great composure as well. It cannot be easy to recount the events surrounding the murder of one's father, as you said, at the dinner table in your own home, and to be witnessed by your mother and your siblings as well. It just goes without saying the pain and the appalling circumstances that your family were throwing into due to that awful murder and the collusion that brought that murder about. As my colleague, Senator Neil Blaney, said, I just want to reiterate on behalf of the Fianna Fáil party that we believe that there has to be a full public inquiry. That is our firm belief, and I heartily endorse Senator O'Donnell's motion. As has been said by colleagues, this is an important week, as the Secretary of State has indicated, that he will be making the decision before the end of the month. I would agree that the deliberations and the outcome of this meeting should be conveyed to the Office of the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland as well, that we have the Oireachtas in different, be it in the plenary session, the Shannad, and also a committee calling for a full public inquiry. Successive governments have reaffirmed this position since the agreement was made in Weston Park in 2001. You know, when two sovereign governments make an agreement, you expect the agreement to be honoured. The Irish government honoured their part of that agreement, and it is way beyond time for the British government to honour the commitments they made as well. I just want to say that, John, you and your mother and other family members have campaigned with great dignity and with great courage over the years, and it cannot be easy to always retain such dignity and such composure. I want to compliment you and you exemplify that so well here this morning in your powerful presentation as well. I listened to the Taoiseach at Leader's Questions on Tuesday and he reiterated that he had met your mother and yourself on Monday. I think it was, and he used the phrase that the full weight of the Taoiseach's office would be behind your family in your quest to get a full public inquiry in your campaign and in your efforts. I think I paraphrase the teacher accurately. Again, as has been said by colleagues, there has been international interest and support for your efforts. I think the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe in September is an important intervention as well. I just want to reiterate that it is sad that we have to be discussing such an issue 31 years after the mother and father, nearly so many years after an agreement made between two sovereign governments that have not been honoured. Of course, as Senator Crockwell referred to other horrendous deeds and loss of life and injury inflicted on so many people due to collusion and due to the atrocities perpetrated and supported by state forces as well. At this Committee, often in the past we discussed the Dublin Monaghan bombings, where the Oireachtas, on a number of occasions, have unanimously appealed to the British Government to give access to an independent legal person, access to the papers surrounding the Dublin Monaghan bombings, the atrocities and other atrocities that have taken place in my own constituency in Cavernman and and throughout Northern Ireland as well. Those are all legacy issues that need to be addressed. No matter how painful it is for whoever or whatever state organisation, the truth has to be uppermost in everybody's efforts. But today is the day that we are concentrating on this particular motion. And again, I compliment you, John, and your family on the great dignity that you have carried out your campaign. We sincerely hope that the campaign for a full public inquiry will be reached within days. So, thank you again for your presentation. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
Thank you for downloading 🙏
If you publish this material on social media, we would be very grateful if you tagged VideoParliament. It helps us reach more people and keep building a transparent archive of Irish politics.