Menu
VideoParliament
VideoParliament Irish politics in one place — download the app
Get app
VideoParliament
VideoParliament for Windows Get the desktop app — notifications about new speeches
Get app
Paul Murphy demands domestic violence refuge for Carlow

Paul Murphy demands domestic violence refuge for Carlow

Paul Murphy pressed the minister over the absence of a domestic violence refuge in Carlow, arguing the county urgently needs local safe accommodation for women and children. He warned that despite reports, temporary units and campaign efforts, Carlow still lacks a full-time refuge and victims are being relocated to other counties.

Call for refuge in Carlow


Paul Murphy highlighted the Carlow Women's Refuge Campaign and Councillor Adrian Wallace's long-running calls for a local refuge. He said over 500 incidents of domestic abuse were reported to Gardaí in Carlow in the first nine months of the year and stressed that temporary emergency accommodation is inadequate when women and children are being sent to Kilkenny, Kildare and Dublin.

Department response and remit


The minister replied that his Department has no direct involvement in establishing a domestic violence refuge in Carlow and pointed to the Minister for Justice and the Domestic Violence Act 2018 as the primary arena for domestic violence policy. The minister outlined his Department's mission to promote rural and community development and to support national organisations such as Women's Aid, Rape Crisis Network Ireland and the National Women's Council of Ireland.

SICAP and local supports in Carlow


The minister described SICAP as the country's primary social inclusion intervention, noting funding of £220 million for 2018-2023 and that since January 2018, 1,138 individuals in Carlow have been supported through the programme. He said €39 million was allocated to SICAP this year and Budget 2022 secured an additional €4 million - a 10% increase which the minister said will fund an extra 60 community workers nationwide. The Community Services Programme was also cited as supporting over 2,000 positions in more than 400 local organisations.

Local research and expert findings


Paul Murphy and the minister both referenced local research and reports: a 2019 Carlow County Development Company study on family homelessness, a 2019 TUSLA needs analysis that endorsed refuge provision, and a 2018 report by Dr Brendan O'Keefe that warned women and children are often forced to remain in violent homes without refuge. The Carlow County Development Company has proposed commissioning further research into an appropriate refuge model in its 2022 annual plan.

Paul Murphy — still from statement: Paul Murphy demands domestic violence refuge for Carlow (14.10.2021)

Budget measures for victim supports


The minister pointed to Budget measures relevant to victims of domestic, sexual and gender-based violence - including a funding package to extend legal aid, a €5 million increase in victim supports bringing total spending to €13 million, €1 million for Guarded Division and Protective Services units, and an additional €3.3 million to support the Legal Aid Board's work for victims.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.

Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →

Transcript
Minister, Over the last two years we have seen a shadow pandemic of violence against women, yet in many rural communities and whole counties such as Carlow there is no domestic violence refuge available. The Carlow Women's Refuge Campaign, supported by Councillor Adrian Wallace, have long been pushing for this injustice to be corrected. Numerous reports and experts have recommended it, two temporary emergency accommodation units have been provided, but it is far from adequate. Do we agree that Carlow needs refuge? Thank you, Deputy, for the question. Just to confirm initially to the Deputy that my Department has no direct involvement in the establishment of a domestic violence refuge in Carlow, I understand that the main domestic violence issues are a matter for the Minister for Justice and are legislated for in the Domestic Violence Act 2018. My Department's mission is to promote rural and community development and to support vibrant, inclusive and sustainable communities throughout Ireland. A key objective of all my Department's programmes is that they are targeted at those sectors, areas and individuals most in need and at providing effective responses to ongoing and future economic and social challenges through the scheme to support national organisations. This includes Women's Aid, Rape Crisis Network Ireland and the National Women's Council of Ireland. My Department also administers the Social Inclusion and Community Activation Programme. This is the country's primary social inclusion intervention. It has funding of £220 million for 2018 to 2023. Its aim is to reduce poverty and promote social inclusion and equality by supporting communities and individuals using community development approaches, engagement and collaboration. Also of some relevance is my Department's Community Services Programme, which also supports community organisations to deliver local services and create employment opportunities for disadvantaged people through a social enterprise model. The programme provides a funding contribution to over 2,000 positions in over 400 community organisations around the country. My Department is providing SICAP funding in excess of £220 million as mentioned. This year, €39 million was allocated and I am delighted to say that in Budget 2022, an additional €4 million has been secured for SICAP. This represents a 10% budget increase for the programme, resulting in an additional 60 community workers nationwide. I accept that this is not the primary responsibility of the Minister. The question is, as the Department for Rural and Community Affairs, you should be supporting the fight for rural communities to get the services that they need. I would ask you to add your name to the list of those calling for women's refuge in Carlow, obviously not just Carlow, all the counties without one. I will give you some striking statistics. There are over 500 incidents of domestic abuse reported to Garde and Carlow in the first nine months of this year alone, but no local domestic violence refuge for those who need it. Instead, people are being sent to Kilkenny, Kildare and even Dublin, causing unnecessary additional distress, uprooting their lives. The problem has been highlighted again and again. Father Peter Mcvery described the situation, the absence of a refuge in Carlow, as scandalous. Thank you Deputy. To acknowledge your point, but also to add that since January 2018, 1,138 individuals have been supported through the SICAP programme in Carlow. The supports offered vary to the individual circumstances, an example of some supports are personal development, lifelong learning course, health and wellbeing and other labour market supports. I would say that Carlow County Development Company carried out research in 2019 on family homelessness which highlighted the plight of women affected by domestic violence and the need for women's refuge in Carlow. They liaise with and refer women to the outreach worker from Amber Kilkinney Refuge and Carlow Women's Aid. Staff have supported women in crisis situations to access women's refuge services. In their 2022 annual plan, they have proposed to commission research into the ongoing need for a domestic violence refuge in Carlow and what model would be most appropriate. This issue has been going on now and been highlighted, the absence of a refuge, for a whole number of years. Back in 2018, there was a report on the homelessness in Carlow by Dr Brendan O'Keefe which highlighted how women and children are often forced to stay in violent homes for the lack of a refuge. TUSLA's own needs analysis in 2019 accepted that a refuge is the most effective means for protecting women and children. The Carlow Women's Refuge campaign was set up back in 2018 and an emergency motion was passed by Carlow County Council in 2019. All the experts agree that a proper full-time refuge that offers all the safety and supports, including childminding and counselling, is what is necessary in terms of safe accommodation for women and children. Some useful points, I think, from the Budget, particularly in relation to the Department of Justice. A funding package will be provided to extend legal aid for victims of domestic sexual and gender-based violence. Spending on victim supports for people who have suffered domestic sexual and gender-based violence is also set to increase by €5 million, bringing it up to €13 million. Some include €1 million to improve Guarded Division and Protective Services units. These are units now operating in every Guarded Division to provide a consistent and professional approach to the investigation of sexual crime, child abuse and domestic abuse. Funding for ongoing training for guardian priority areas such as combating domestic sexual and gender-based violence, an additional €3.3 million to support the work of the Legal Aid Board, including the provision of legal advice and legal aid service to victims of sexual offences. Another point of relevance in terms of rent supplement, if you are a victim of domestic violence you will be able to apply for rent supplement on referral by Tusla, where an application is made for rent supplement will be provided for initial three months and will not require a means test. Thank you very much. Thank you.