Menu
VideoParliament
VideoParliament Irish politics in one place — download the app
Get app
VideoParliament
VideoParliament for Windows Get the desktop app — notifications about new speeches
Get app
Gino Kenny: Calls for fairer redress for mother and baby survivors

Gino Kenny: Calls for fairer redress for mother and baby survivors

Gino Kenny addressed the minister about survivors of mother and baby homes and criticised the government compensation scheme. He argued the scheme is flawed and arbitrary, and he drew on his family's personal experience to call for better recognition and redress.

Main critique of the compensation scheme


Gino Kenny said there are many flaws with the scheme, highlighting the arbitrary nature of eligibility. He questioned why people who spent less than six months in institutions receive no compensation and said that omission feels like an insult, while making clear he did not blame the minister personally for past crimes.

Personal family testimony


Kenny recounted his mother giving evidence to the Commission of Investigation after spending time in one of the institutions. He described the trauma his mother and sister experienced, including the mother being separated from her baby daughter for more than 30 years and the powerful emotion when they were finally reunited.

Historical description of institutions


He described mother and baby homes as institutions of the State and the Catholic Church, created to banish and punish so-called "fallen women" for having children out of wedlock. He characterised that history as a deeply, deeply painful past for survivors.

State recognition and compensation


Kenny said that, despite the past not being changeable, the scheme can readdress some financial compensation and offer a form of recognition from the state. He expressed hope that survivors will feel acknowledged for the terrible wrongs done to them, even if those wrongs cannot be fully reversed.

Gino Kenny — still from statement: Gino Kenny: Calls for fairer redress for mother and baby survivors (25.11.2021)

Emotional impact on survivors


Throughout his remarks he stressed the widespread pain caused by the institutions and the importance of acknowledging survivors' suffering. He framed compensation and recognition as steps toward making wrongs right and offering some solace to those affected.

We publish thousands of recordings to make Irish politics transparent and resistant to manipulation. Spotted an error? Report it — together we are building a reliable archive of Irish politics.

Tego samego dnia All speeches from this day →

Transcript
Minister, there are many, many things that we can't change in the past, even though we would want to, but we can't. The past is sometimes in the past, and the present is the present. And survivors of mother and baby institutions, it was a deeply, deeply painful past. And mother and baby homes, or institutions, were an institution of the State and the Catholic Church. And they were for fallen women, quote-unquote, to be banished and to be punished for the crimes of having children out of wedlock. And I will get to my own personal experience of that. Minister, there are many flaws with this scheme, particularly around the arbitrary nature of those that spent time in these institutions. I don't really understand why, if somebody had spent less than six months, there is not some sort of compensation or some sort of redress. I think it's slightly an insult. And I'm not blaming you personally, because you weren't to blame for the crimes of the past, but you can readdress the future. And the reason why I say I have personal, my mother gave evidence in the Commission of Investigation, and my mother spent a period of time in one of the institutions. And it was extremely traumatic. Very traumatic for my mother and my sister, which I would meet eventually, over a period of time. And my mother's account is quite harrowing. Her baby daughter was taken away from her, and not to see her daughter for 30-odd years. And I'll always remember to the day I die, of when my mother found out that she was going to meet her daughter again. I'll never forget it. I thought my mother was, well, she was crying, and kind of joyous in one sense, that eventually, you know, the daughter that was taken away from her, she was going to meet again. And it was a very painful time in all our lives. And so in some ways, the juxtaposition of that, but also meeting, you know, a person that my mother thought was gone. And, you know, we met her again. So, Minister, there's a lot to be said, you know, in relation to what has happened, you know, and there's so much pain out there in relation to what has happened. But I think in some ways, in some ways, the scheme can readdress some of the financial compensation in relation to those women that went through this pretty, pretty horrible process. And hopefully, hopefully, the women that went through them institutions will have some sort of, I suppose, in their own minds, they were kind of recognised by the state, the terrible wrongs that were known to them, the terrible wrongs that can't, in some ways, can't be reversed. But at least, you know, the state have said, you know, this was the terrible wrongs and we will try to make them right. Thanks.